Eli Manning signs ridiculous extension!

[wdleehi]

So you are saying if the cardinals played in Ny Warner wouldent do well?

Warner didn't do well in NY.  

[Rondo2287]

Ok your right the point is that warner is better than Eli, sorry for getting off topic

[wdleehi]

Eli is a great fit for the Giants.


Because of that fit, they won a Super Bowl.


And because of that fit, they are SB contenders again. 


End of story.

[Rondo2287]

They will win 8 games this year, because ELi cannot win without an elite WR, unlike Tom Brady.  End of story

[wdleehi]

They will win 8 games this year, because ELi cannot win without an elite WR, unlike Tom Brady.  End of story

Proof? 


Or just bias opinion?

[crownsy]

Eli is a great fit for the Giants.


Because of that fit, they won a Super Bowl.


And because of that fit, they are SB contenders again. 


End of story.

I don't think they are SB contenders this year unless they add a High quality WR.

If they do, then i'll rethink my stance. but right now they aren't deep enough at WR.

I think there a playoff team right now, but not a superbowl team.

[ssspence]

Ok your right the point is that warner is better than Eli, sorry for getting off topic

yeah definitely -- and mcnabb too. and don't forget aaron rodgers. would you trade manning for both of them too?

[Rondo2287]

Didnt somebody say that he was 1-4 without burress and he didnt throw a TD to a WR after Burress left, and now Toomer is gone too.  And the running game will be hurt even more this year with ward being gone and I have yet to see Jacobs hold up for a full year.  Which puts more pressure on Eli and he will be exposed

[Rondo2287]

Ok your right the point is that warner is better than Eli, sorry for getting off topic

yeah definitely -- and mcnabb too. and don't forget aaron rodgers. would you trade manning for both of them too?

Please stop dodging my points and just coming back with sarcastic remarks.  In what way is Eli Manning better than Warner? 

[ssspence]

Eli is a great fit for the Giants.


Because of that fit, they won a Super Bowl.


And because of that fit, they are SB contenders again. 


End of story.

I don't think they are SB contenders this year unless they add a High quality WR.

If they do, then i'll rethink my stance. but right now they aren't deep enough at WR.

I think there a playoff team right now, but not a superbowl team.

actually their depth at receiver is better than you think. but i agree that they need some guys to step up. i believe a couple of those guys have to tools -- nicks and manningham especially. just because guys haven't played in the league doesn't mean they won't be good.

[wdleehi]

Eli is a great fit for the Giants.


Because of that fit, they won a Super Bowl.


And because of that fit, they are SB contenders again. 


End of story.

I don't think they are SB contenders this year unless they add a High quality WR.

If they do, then i'll rethink my stance. but right now they aren't deep enough at WR.

I think there a playoff team right now, but not a superbowl team.

Top defense

Top rushing attack

Top QB


And even though they are not top names (nor the talent level of Burress), They have WR talent that for the first time, will be the passing focus in the off season.  They step up like they have the ability to (and not drop easy TDs in the playoffs against Philly), They will be fine.

[crownsy]

Eli is a great fit for the Giants.


Because of that fit, they won a Super Bowl.


And because of that fit, they are SB contenders again. 


End of story.

I don't think they are SB contenders this year unless they add a High quality WR.

If they do, then i'll rethink my stance. but right now they aren't deep enough at WR.

I think there a playoff team right now, but not a superbowl team.

Top defense

Top rushing attack

Top QB


And even though they are not top names (nor the talent level of Burress), They have WR talent that for the first time, will be the passing focus in the off season.  They step up like they have the ability to (and not drop easy TDs in the playoffs against Philly), They will be fine.

We shall see my friend 

[Rondo2287]

Eli is a great fit for the Giants.


Because of that fit, they won a Super Bowl.


And because of that fit, they are SB contenders again. 


End of story.

I don't think they are SB contenders this year unless they add a High quality WR.

If they do, then i'll rethink my stance. but right now they aren't deep enough at WR.

I think there a playoff team right now, but not a superbowl team.

Top defense

TopOften Injured rushing attack

TopSlightly Above Average QB


And even though they are not top names (nor the talent level of Burress), They have WR talent that for the first time, will be the passing focus in the off season.  They step up like they have the ability to (and not drop easy TDs in the playoffs against Philly), They will be fine.

Fixed

[wdleehi]

Ok your right the point is that warner is better than Eli, sorry for getting off topic

yeah definitely -- and mcnabb too. and don't forget aaron rodgers. would you trade manning for both of them too?

Please stop dodging my points and just coming back with sarcastic remarks.  In what way is Eli Manning better than Warner? 

1) younger
2) won the same amount of Super Bowls
3) has never lost a job in the NFL
4) has never missed the playoffs as a day 1 starter
5) can handle NY

[wdleehi]

They will win 8 games this year, because ELi cannot win without an elite WR, unlike Tom Brady.  End of story

Proof? 


Or just bias opinion?

Still waiting.