I am much happier if Buchholz is not a part of this deal. Plus, if he is not, that means we still have an outside, small chance at pulling off something major with the Jays if they get desperate enough at deadline. Landing Martinez and a top of line pitcher would be ideal.
Personally, I view the value of a 25 year old up and coming pitcher with potential top 2 starting stuff much greater then a 31 year old catcher/1b/dh who has probably peaked. I know I might be in the minority but I did not feel Theo would use Buchholz for this caliber of player