I don't think I have great NFL draft instincts, but if the choice is between:
(1) sign a top WR for $25M-$30M/year (even Tee Higgins seems to want this, and he might be more of a #2 guy)
(2) draft an OL in the top 10
OR;
(1) draft a WR in the top-10 on the rookie scale - and top WR prospects are increasingly becoming #1s
(2) have $25M-$30M to spend on the OL/DL
Which path is more reliable? Are WRs overpriced on the open market?
I would personally go #1.
That way, you assure yourself a legit #1 WR that is young (Higgins) and then get either Campbell or Banks probably somewhere in the 8-10 range. If you have a Top-6 pick, trade down for more assets and still take the OT with the first round pick.
I love Tet but to me, OT is a legitimate need and like others have said, this team is allergic to selecting talented WRs in the Draft. The 2019 draft literally had all legit prospects and we chose the one bum (N'Keal Harry) lol
Another thing to consider is that there are some legit WRs potentially available this offseason (Higgins in FA, Metcalf via trade, etc.) but the tackle/guard FA market isn't that hot. I would personally draft a tackle in the 1st round, and then sign a solid guard in FA
I agree with you, I get we have somewhat new decision makers but the Patriots also have not had any success drafting a wide receiver in like 20 years either. (And polk doesn't look great) Feels like drafting an OL is a little better hit rate for us, although we haven't really done great there either.
On WRs, I would keep in mind:
Top-10 drafted receivers are drastically different from drafting outside the top-30, with Harry (32) and Polk (37) both being guys who could have easily slipped out of the top-50. Recent picks are: M Harrison / M Nabers / R Odunze / D London / G Wilson / J Waddle / J Chase / D Smith. That's basically 100% hit on 1,000 yard receivers, and someone like Tee Higgins would be middle of the pack today.
That and, Tee Higgins is simply not a top-10 receiver for top-10 money.
Meanwhile, Trey Smith is a free agent who IS a top-10 interior lineman in his prime with 2x Super Bowl rings, and will cost a bit less...
Still scared like everyone else about the Pats drafting a WR, but logically it's tempting... ~$30M/year to steal a starting guard in his prime from the champs + best receiver in the draft, or Tee Higgins and a rookie LT?