All this Mayo is horrible talk is so reminiscent of the Mazzulla talk. Bottom 25 coach, then it was never win a title with Mazzulla, then it was they won in spite of him. I said this about Mazzulla at the time and I think it is even more true about Mayo now, there is no way to know if Mayo is a good coach or not, based only on the first season. 12 games of coaching this team tells you nothing. He might be a a bad coach, he might be fine, he might win a title someday.
A very realistic scenario is that we draft Will Campbell and he turns out to be a stud at LT. Cole Strange comes back and plays above average at Center. Caedan Wallace turns out to be just fine at RT. Sow and Onwenu both play at a high level at guard. And suddenly Mayo looks like a way better coach.
I have some concern on the defense. We have lost some players and had some injuries. At times the defense has been decent, but other times, we are just picked apart. We have some holes in terms of personnel but it seems like it is more than that. But again, one season, all new coaching staff, bad team in general, not sure if this is a true reflection on Mayo or not. I would like to see Mayo coach with a better team and not with an entire coaching staff that is together for the first time, before giving up on him.