...
If you look at Sully's Per 36 numbers this year and compare them to Love's Per 36 numbers, they are pretty darn close. Love is +2 on scoring, but Sully is shoots a higher percentage (as scary as that is to say) and is rebounding at a slightly better rate. Sully is way up on assists, and is a significant better defensive player (IMHO) than Love is.
Playing time is also a moot point since Sully averaged just under 28 MPG for the previous two seasons, and the only reason his minutes are down this year is because we have a logjam up front.
...
Playing time is not a moot point because Sully has horrible conditioning.
And why even mention Sully's minutes from previous season if we are only going to look at Love's numbers in Cleveland? If we are going to talk about Sully's previous 2 seasons, we should also consider Love's last season in Minny.
I'm mentioning Sully's previous two seasons
only in relation to minutes played and no other statistic.
The fact that Sully was capable of playing 27-28 MPG the past two seasons shows that despite conditioning concerns, he's still capable of playing starters minutes. He probably can't play 32 or 36 minutes and remain effective, but at 28 minutes he is fine.
On a 'per 28 minute' basis Sully is averaging 11.85 points, 10.17 rebounds, 2.75 assists, 1.08 steals, 0.84 blocks, 1.55 turnovers and 3.35 fouls while shooting 43%/27%/63%.
In 32 minutes Love is averaging 15.7 points, 10.3 rebounds, 2.4 assists, 0.9 steals, 0.6 blocks, 1.8 turnovers and 2.1 fouls while shooting 42%/37%/80%.
So even if you apply a 28 minute cap on Sully's playing time, Love still only gives you the benefit of:
* 4 PPG
* Dependable three point shot
* More consistent free throw shooting
Once again that is a significant enough enough gain to justify upgrading
if the price is right. But I find it very hard to justify giving up a core player that is very important to our team (e.g. Bradley)
and a draft pick with #1 potential, for such a relatively modest upgrade.
Again, I would rather just re-sign Sully and then go after Horford or Dwight in free agency with our abundance of cap space.