Your Boston Celtics:
PG: Chris Paul ( 08-09) Tyreke Evans (09-10), Devin Harris (08-09)
SG: Vince Carter (00-01) Reggie Lewis (91-92)
SF: Jamal Mashburn (02-03) James Posey (03-04)
PF: Dirk Nowitzki (05-06) Juwan Howard (95-96) Antawn Jamison (07-08)
C: Marc Gasol (11-12) Andrew Bogut (07-08) Kendrick Perkins (08-09)
I agree with you all. This team leaves you speechless.
I think the panelists disagree with my viewpoint but I like your team more with James Posey starting and Mashburn in that reserve role.
I wasn't impressed with Mashburn in Miami when he had to share the ball with Timmy Hardaway and Alonzo Mourning. I thought he struggled to play at a high level in that situation and the touches + shot attempts will only get harder for Mashburn to receive in this Boston team.
I like Posey's low usage game and high level defense/rebounding alongside your star talent.
I think Posey's floor spacing is valuable alongside a ball-dominant guard like CP3 and two high powered offensive weapons like Dirk Nowitzki and Vince Carter. Especially with all those pick and rolls and isolation plays. I think that low usage high efficient scoring from Posey will be more useful than a ball-dominant wing like Mashburn.
And then there is the defensive upgrade and possession creation upgrade, slam dunk for me, Posey over Mashburn.