« Reply #313 on: June 11, 2012, 01:24:32 PM »
Well, couldn't we make a similar argument for Lebron? D Rose? etc...
Nope because there isn't a consistent pattern of those teams trading scorers because they couldn't get along with the star. The only player Cleveland traded away was Ricky Davis (who clearly was a head case as evident by all his stops, including Boston). Chicago hasn't traded away any scorers because of Rose and certainly no one mid-season.
To some extent, those players named have had myriad lineup changes, trades, in an effort to build a cohesive unit.
All teams undergo lineup changes. I mean Oklahoma City added Perk mid-season last year for Jeff Green for basketball reasons. They didn't trade away Green because he didn't get along with Durant. They also still have Westbrook and Harden and didn't trade them away because they couldn't get along with Durant. Contending teams trade away role players, they don't trade away their second best player, like Philly did year after year because of Iverson.
CP3, too.
CP3's had Tyson Prime, David West Prime, Blake Griffin, DeAndre Jordan, Caron Butler, etc - and the farthest he's been in the playoffs, still, is to the WCF's.
What does that have to do with anything? West left as a free agent, Paul and Griffin get along fine. There weren't these mass of mid-season trades involving Paul's teams where the Hornets got rid of their second best player because him and Paul couldn't get along.
In other words, there is definitely more to AI's teams not fairing well than what is on the surface.
Who said anything about fairing well. Iverson's Philly teams were actually pretty good, the question is how Iverson would fit with a team full of superstars in a league full of superstar teams, and in that I think he would fair incredibly poorly based on how he interacted with other "star" players throughout his entire career.
So you REALLY believe that Allen Iverson would perform poorly with a team of Mitch Richmond and Amar'e Prime?
I'd like to think that THOSE two were better than ANY other combo that Allen Iverson played with.
IMO, it is just TOO arbitrary to come up with a summary to say that Allen Iverson wouldn't flourish in THIS format. If I were AI, in THIS format, I'd wake up with a smile on my face every day knowing I had Mitch and amar'e to carry the load.
That's why even Micheal Jordan's greatness can be called into question in some regards. The man played with one of the best SF's of all time in Scottie....CERTAINLY the BEST Defensive SF to ever play the game.
Look at Michael's teams throughout his career - the ONE constant has been Scottie and Phil. Everyone else (including Dennis Rodman, Horace Grant, Tony Kukoc) have been a variable.
Too bad AI never had Scottie.
I think Allen Iverson has consistently shown he has trouble sharing the spot light and deferring the scoring load to someone else. It was shown time and time again throughout his career. I don't think that changes when you put him on a team of superstars in a league full of superstar teams.

Logged
2023 Historical Draft - Brooklyn Nets - 9th pick
Bigs - Pau, Amar'e, Issel, McGinnis, Roundfield
Wings - Dantley, Bowen, J. Jackson
Guards - Cheeks, Petrovic, Buse, Rip