Well according to the NBA first and second team voting Amare was the 6th best player in the league who I believe I got in the middle of the first round. Shaq was a disappointment but he would have been more effective in the half court flex offense I was running with the Clippers. I also had Corey Maggette who only averaged around 20 points a game. I also had Peja who was completely deadly for the Hornets. If I had the complete list of my players in front of me now I would be better equipped to defend myself. I rememeber that when we presented our team I got a lot of support for the idea that I would win the West. (Anyway you could give me links to last years threads)
This year I will continue to do what I did well last year and improve upon the mistakes that I made (absolutely no way I pick Shaq this year, and people killed me for not having a pure point).
Not to get into this debate, but I'm 95% sure you didn't have Maggette, since I drafted him and trade him to Portland's GM at the time.

I'm just teasing you with the Amare / Shaq stuff, though.
It's interesting to see how things worked out, though. For instance, I traded Maggette and Corey Brewer for Bargnani and Mike Dunleavy. Who knew that Maggette and Dunleavy would be the stars of that trade, and Bargnani and Brewer would be such disappointments? I loved my late round picks, though: Ronnie Brewer in the 12th and K. Azubuike in the 13th. That turned out brilliantly. Really, in hindsight, the only pick I would want back is the Bargnani one; everything else worked out spectacularly.
Unfortunately, though, we had a crash in our archives, and pretty much everything prior to mid-April this season is gone.