West starting lineup vs East starting lineup
C: Jokic vs Bam
F: Durant vs Giannis
F: LeBron vs Tatum
G: Doncic vs Haliburton
G: SGA vs Lillard
This is the problem with calling Luka a guard. He is not a guard. He is a forward. He is a slow forward. Not a SF or a PF but a slow forward. A slow forward who needs to be paired with a quick forward who can defend so Luka can be hidden. Like Larry Bird had with Cedric Maxwell, later Kevin McHale and later again Kevin Gamble. Someone with the footspeed and defensive versatility to hide Luka.
So we have Luka who is a slow forward. We have LeBron who is a 39 year old slow forward. We have Durant who is a 35 year old slow forward. Then we have Jokic who is a slow center. So one slow big man, three slow forwards and only one guard. Only one player with good quickness in SGA.
Look at the East squad. Bam is a high level athlete. Giannis is slowing down a bit but still a good athlete. Tatum is a superior athlete. Then two guards with good speed in Haliburton and Lillard. In an open court game like the ASG, that five man lineup was always going to the run the West off the court. The West was simply too slow.
And large chunk of that comes down to pretending Luka is a guard. Imagine subbing out LeBron or Durant for Anthony Edwards. Ant and SGA in the backcourt. Now that is something to work with. Still slow in the frontcourt but at least you are somewhat competitive speed wise. Too dang slow.
Maybe that's why those specific positions are going away now and people like Brad Stevens just look at players as ball handlers, wings and bigs. There's obviously then subcategories within those, like stretch big, rim protector, point forward, score-first PG, etc. But the way the voting works, they still have the five positions that James Naismith originally came up with in 1891, that most of us grew up watching until the game started to change around the turn of the century.
I never saw Luka as a guard, I always saw him as a point forward - a ball handling wing. But defensively I don't think he can defend more traditional ball handlers, especially score-first PGs like Dame.