Create Your Own Pub Experience: Draft Thread

[Gainesville Celtic]

Is it really?  Everyone knows what a dance floor is.  IP is just trying to act clever.

If the bar clears space to allow people to dance, it's promoting dancing.  I think Edgar's pick precludes that (or at least, Rondo2287 ruled that way.)

Here's my problem with the pick - it's just too vague.  

I think we're being overtly generous as is. He's selecting a DJ, and you're arguing Roy that he should get the exclusive rights to literally everything that relates to a 'dance scene.' Even down to dancing. Which really makes it about 300 picks not one.

Not really.  Edgar's bar activity is dancing, and everything that goes with that.  Champ's is TV + all cable rights + pay per view (i.e., all the parts that make up a full TV experience).  I don't see them being any different at all. 

Given how many posts have been uh... posted... on this topic, I'm going to choose "arguing about meaningless, fictional things to the point where it starts to turn others off" as my activity.

then you'll HAVE to come to my bar... and I'll shoot myself  

[Edgar]

And StarOrien, I have a circus with 70000 acts, and thats just being good picking not generalizing.

But in this case you're saying, I'll take the circus and the entertainment that comes along with it.

You're not requesting to have a circus, exclusive rights to seating, and lighting.

I requested to have THE BEST insert profanity circus in the world.
Without animal cruelty
and over 7000acts from all over the world to show in my pub
thats totally fair
considerin pearl jam has like 300 songs.

[StartOrien]

Is it really?  Everyone knows what a dance floor is.  IP is just trying to act clever.

If the bar clears space to allow people to dance, it's promoting dancing.  I think Edgar's pick precludes that (or at least, Rondo2287 ruled that way.)

Here's my problem with the pick - it's just too vague.  

I think we're being overtly generous as is. He's selecting a DJ, and you're arguing Roy that he should get the exclusive rights to literally everything that relates to a 'dance scene.' Even down to dancing. Which really makes it about 300 picks not one.

Not really.  Edgar's bar activity is dancing, and everything that goes with that.  Champ's is TV + all cable rights + pay per view (i.e., all the parts that make up a full TV experience).  I don't see them being any different at all. 

This is going to sound way more dramatic than I want -

But the pick of 'dancing' just goes against everything this draft is about, and really is just a way of exploiting an inaugural draft with categories that are inherently vague.

[chicagoceltic]

Is it really?  Everyone knows what a dance floor is.  IP is just trying to act clever.

If the bar clears space to allow people to dance, it's promoting dancing.  I think Edgar's pick precludes that (or at least, Rondo2287 ruled that way.)

Here's my problem with the pick - it's just too vague.  

I think we're being overtly generous as is. He's selecting a DJ, and you're arguing Roy that he should get the exclusive rights to literally everything that relates to a 'dance scene.' Even down to dancing. Which really makes it about 300 picks not one.

Not really.  Edgar's bar activity is dancing, and everything that goes with that.  Champ's is TV + all cable rights + pay per view (i.e., all the parts that make up a full TV experience).  I don't see them being any different at all. 

Ok, is Edgar's bar activty dancing or is his entertainment a DJ?  You can't really roll both into a single pick, can you?

His activity is dancing, complete with a live DJ.

That's one activity.  Clubs and bars all over the world promote this as their activity.  "Live DJ Dancing".  It's a bar activity, that we've all seen promoted in every city in the country.  That's what Edgar is selecting.

Ok, I see a DJ as more entertainment but then again, it's just a game of make believe we are playing so I'm fine with it.

[indeedproceed]

I think this officially just got a little too complicated.

Edgar took a DJ, does that mean Paul Oakenfold is off the list? We can't dance to a DJ, but can we do the Humpty Hump, Do The Humpty Hump, if we choose Digital Underground?

If we host a wedding, can we do the chicken dance, as long as we stay near our seats?

Its simple, Edgar's bar has a dedicated space that's a 24 hour rave, where women sweat sensuously and drink long island iced teas, and men clumsily try to keep up without looking too happy to be there.

Kinda like this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wkjesl8DNmo

[Edgar]

The Rusty Nail Saloon Selects: Grain Alcohol

What grains?
 
this could ended being brilliant  

[Lucky17]

Coming late to the party.

Re: Edgar's pick, he's not really picking "dancing", he's picking "(night)clubbing" as his activity, isn't he?

Also, a live DJ is an individual, and has a professional name/persona (otherwise, why do clubs advertise which DJ is playing on any given night?), so I see it as two separate picks.

My two cents.

[Gainesville Celtic]

Is it really?  Everyone knows what a dance floor is.  IP is just trying to act clever.

If the bar clears space to allow people to dance, it's promoting dancing.  I think Edgar's pick precludes that (or at least, Rondo2287 ruled that way.)

Here's my problem with the pick - it's just too vague. 

I think we're being overtly generous as is. He's selecting a DJ, and you're arguing Roy that he should get the exclusive rights to literally everything that relates to a 'dance scene.' Even down to dancing. Which really makes it about 300 picks not one.

Not really.  Edgar's bar activity is dancing, and everything that goes with that.  Champ's is TV + all cable rights + pay per view (i.e., all the parts that make up a full TV experience).  I don't see them being any different at all. 

Ok, is Edgar's bar activty dancing or is his entertainment a DJ?  You can't really roll both into a single pick, can you?

His activity is dancing, complete with a live DJ.

That's one activity.  Clubs and bars all over the world promote this as their activity.  "Live DJ Dancing".  It's a bar activity, that we've all seen promoted in every city in the country.  That's what Edgar is selecting.

Ok, I see a DJ as more entertainment but then again, it's just a game of make believe we are playing so I'm fine with it.

Wait.... what?!?

Make believe? Are you sure? Well then how in the world did I just get subpoenaed by Roy H. in the case:

-----------------------------

Portland Crotornats Pub LLC
(Plaintiff)
     
      v.

Fun
(Defendant)

-----------------------------------

Can someone let me know if this is in-fact make believe and/or fun, or FOR SERIOUS?!?!

[chicagoceltic]

I think everyone needs to chill out and go to Sam N Ella's to see Louis C.K. and get a good laugh...

[Edgar]

why do clubs advertise which DJ is playing on any given night?),

Because they have the place to put the DJs


p.s. I am not answer more on this. So feel free to do what you like I am just going to hang up a big sing of Live Djs outside my bar and see how it get filled by Young ladies not interested in Russian Acts , MJ , Kriss angel and th beattles.

Look for it on floors 2 and 3 of the Panda Pub.

[Roy H.]

Is it really?  Everyone knows what a dance floor is.  IP is just trying to act clever.

If the bar clears space to allow people to dance, it's promoting dancing.  I think Edgar's pick precludes that (or at least, Rondo2287 ruled that way.)

Here's my problem with the pick - it's just too vague.  

I think we're being overtly generous as is. He's selecting a DJ, and you're arguing Roy that he should get the exclusive rights to literally everything that relates to a 'dance scene.' Even down to dancing. Which really makes it about 300 picks not one.

Not really.  Edgar's bar activity is dancing, and everything that goes with that.  Champ's is TV + all cable rights + pay per view (i.e., all the parts that make up a full TV experience).  I don't see them being any different at all.  

Ok, is Edgar's bar activty dancing or is his entertainment a DJ?  You can't really roll both into a single pick, can you?

His activity is dancing, complete with a live DJ.

That's one activity.  Clubs and bars all over the world promote this as their activity.  "Live DJ Dancing".  It's a bar activity, that we've all seen promoted in every city in the country.  That's what Edgar is selecting.

Ok, I see a DJ as more entertainment but then again, it's just a game of make believe we are playing so I'm fine with it.

Wait.... what?!?

Make believe? Are you sure? Well then how in the world did I just get subpoenaed by Roy H. in the case:

-----------------------------

Portland Crotornats Pub LLC
(Plaintiff)
      
      v.

Fun
(Defendant)

-----------------------------------

Can someone let me know if this is in-fact make believe and/or fun, or FOR SERIOUS?!?!

<Biting tongue, as Roy H.'s inner lawyer seethes about the "fun" of arbitrary, inconsistent rules>

Move on, please. 

[chicagoceltic]

Is it really?  Everyone knows what a dance floor is.  IP is just trying to act clever.

If the bar clears space to allow people to dance, it's promoting dancing.  I think Edgar's pick precludes that (or at least, Rondo2287 ruled that way.)

Here's my problem with the pick - it's just too vague. 

I think we're being overtly generous as is. He's selecting a DJ, and you're arguing Roy that he should get the exclusive rights to literally everything that relates to a 'dance scene.' Even down to dancing. Which really makes it about 300 picks not one.

Not really.  Edgar's bar activity is dancing, and everything that goes with that.  Champ's is TV + all cable rights + pay per view (i.e., all the parts that make up a full TV experience).  I don't see them being any different at all. 

Ok, is Edgar's bar activty dancing or is his entertainment a DJ?  You can't really roll both into a single pick, can you?

His activity is dancing, complete with a live DJ.

That's one activity.  Clubs and bars all over the world promote this as their activity.  "Live DJ Dancing".  It's a bar activity, that we've all seen promoted in every city in the country.  That's what Edgar is selecting.

Ok, I see a DJ as more entertainment but then again, it's just a game of make believe we are playing so I'm fine with it.

Wait.... what?!?

Make believe? Are you sure? Well then how in the world did I just get subpoenaed by Roy H. in the case:

-----------------------------

Portland Crotornats Pub LLC
(Plaintiff)
     
      v.

Fun
(Defendant)

-----------------------------------

Can someone let me know if this is in-fact make believe and/or fun, or FOR SERIOUS?!?!

^good stuff there...TP to you. 

[Edgar]

Is it really?  Everyone knows what a dance floor is.  IP is just trying to act clever.

If the bar clears space to allow people to dance, it's promoting dancing.  I think Edgar's pick precludes that (or at least, Rondo2287 ruled that way.)

Here's my problem with the pick - it's just too vague. 

I think we're being overtly generous as is. He's selecting a DJ, and you're arguing Roy that he should get the exclusive rights to literally everything that relates to a 'dance scene.' Even down to dancing. Which really makes it about 300 picks not one.

Not really.  Edgar's bar activity is dancing, and everything that goes with that.  Champ's is TV + all cable rights + pay per view (i.e., all the parts that make up a full TV experience).  I don't see them being any different at all. 

Ok, is Edgar's bar activty dancing or is his entertainment a DJ?  You can't really roll both into a single pick, can you?

His activity is dancing, complete with a live DJ.

That's one activity.  Clubs and bars all over the world promote this as their activity.  "Live DJ Dancing".  It's a bar activity, that we've all seen promoted in every city in the country.  That's what Edgar is selecting.

Ok, I see a DJ as more entertainment but then again, it's just a game of make believe we are playing so I'm fine with it.

Wait.... what?!?

Make believe? Are you sure? Well then how in the world did I just get subpoenaed by Roy H. in the case:

-----------------------------

Portland Crotornats Pub LLC
(Plaintiff)
     
      v.

Fun
(Defendant)

-----------------------------------

Can someone let me know if this is in-fact make believe and/or fun, or FOR SERIOUS?!?!

because I am the fun part

[Edgar]

See you on round 6 later today

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f67TZEFndmM

[indeedproceed]

I cannot wait to write my Yelp review.

"The bar smelled of rich mahogany and desperation as I entered, and I knew I was home."