My team is a playoff team, I have the best point guard in the league. When was the last time the best player at any position in the NBA didn't at least make the playoffs? How about the second best player at any position? It just doesn't happen. That's not to say I don't have good defensive veterans throughout the team and young athletic fliers to run with Deron.
I understand that some people don't view my team as a contender for a championship but for me to not make the playoffs is ridiculous.
I think your squad 9th or 10th in the West. Just outside the playoffs.
I think your team is a playoff caliber team in normal circumstances but there were a lot of very good teams in the West in this fantasy game and I thought they offered a little bit more than your roster.
The main reason why I did not put your team in the playoffs is Josh Howard. I don't have confidence in him to return from his injury and play at a high level anymore. I still like his defensive ability but I question his ability to be a good go-to scorer (efficiency?) + I don't think he can rebound his position (SF) anymore.
If Josh Howard did come back healthy + was able to regain his form of a few years ago ... I would have Minny in the playoffs.
I don't think he needs to be a go to scorer anymore, he will be the recipient of playing with Deron Williams which will help his scoring.
If you can't be sold on him Stackhouse was a contributing member of a playoff team at the same position. Quis showed that when healthy he can play good ball at the same position (pre all star break). Then I have Gordon Hayward who will be starting for a Jazz playoff team who can come in and fill the position. Also I have Xavier Henry who had great production for Kansas as a freshman last year and should get open shots with Deron running the show.
All of those players are solid contributors for their roles ... but none are impact players.
A four man core of Deron + high quality wing + J.Smith + Haywood is a very impressive foundation.
A three man core of Deron + Smith + Haywood is solid but unexceptional (surefire playoff team in normal circumstances).
I think you need Josh Howard to be ... maybe not an All-Star but at least a notch or two below that ... to be an impact player ... for your squad to be comparable to the other playoff teams in the West.
I also think Howard's scoring is important to your side. The balance it provides.