My question for Atlanta is when you play Indiana, Chicago, and NY, when the jump ball goes up, who guards Kobe, Wade, and Lebron?
If it's JJ or Hinrich, Kobe is going off 12-14 in the first quarter and likely 35+ for the game. If it's Durant playing D, I'm telling you, he will get awfully tired and it will affect his ability to then be the entire offense on the other end of the floor.
To the poster who asked why Lebron can do it and Durant cannot: From what IP said, Tony Allen, who is lockdown, will guard the primary wing for 20 minutes per game or so. Lebron will probably guard it for the other 20-24 minutes. So that's not all game. And Lebron does steroids, so he doesn't lose any energy playing defense.
OK, on a serious note, they still have Brandon Jennings who can create some offense so Lebron doesn't have to shoulder the entire offensive load like Durant will on his team.
Look super stars are going to get their points that's why they're superstars. You act like everyone has a team that will completely shut down these players.
As we've seen in the playoffs Durant did a pretty good job when he guarded Kobe. Are you going to have Kobe guarding all the other superstars? He's not in his 20's anymore he doesn't have the legs like Durant/Wade/LeBron to chase around other premier players and still have enough left on the other end of the court.
No, I'm definitely not. Mickael Pietrus will be guarding them. Between him and Kobe, I actually do think my team might be able to shut down superstar wings on many nights. I also think that Chicago can between Tony Allen and Lebron. They are a couple of the few teams in the East, I'm not entirely familiar with the West off the top of my head.
No, I don't think every team will be able to "shut down" those players. But I also don't think other teams have defenders who will be exploited like JJ Redick would be like. You say "get their points". Against JJ Redick, I'm not talking about Kobe "getting his 27-30 ppg". Yes, that will happen against most teams. I'm talking about him going off for 35-40 or more on some nights.
I see a great solution to that being, "OK, Durant will guard them then." But then I see the immediate problem being, "wait, we need him literally every single possession on offense." I completely agree with you that Durant can guard them. The question that I feel people are ignoring is whether or not the offense can still function if he does. And if he doesn't, can Durant + Atlanta still manage to outscore the other superstars?