« Reply #384 on: Today at 03:15:32 PM »
Rams/Seahawks game tonight pretty good. 30-30 game.
Crazy Seahawks 2-point conversion that counted to tie the game
I have a question about that play. Upon review, the officials realized that Darnold's attempt was a backwards pass, and thus a fumble and a live ball. This is the correct ruling, but I also noticed during the play that at least one official blew his whistle right before Charbonnet recovered the ball in the end zone -- wouldn't that result in a dead ball and thus eliminate the recovery in the end zone (and the two points)?
Here's the rule:
When an on-field ruling is incomplete, and the pass was clearly backward, the ball will be awarded at the spot of recovery to the team that recovers the ball in the immediate continuing action. If there is no clear recovery, the ball will be awarded to the team last in possession at the spot where possession was lost."
Since ZC made a clear recovery, it's a good call.
I agree that the call was, in a vacuum, correct, but I thought that a whistle means the play is dead, and I heard a whistle. Do they just ignore whistles in those situations?
It's actually addressed.
Terry McAulay
@tjmcaulay
Football rules PSA:
Allow me to provide insight into what I believe is the most misunderstood aspect of officiating/rules.
The "whistle" is irrelevant to the ruling in every situation unless it is erroneous (NFL) or inadvertent (College). In non-erroneous situations, it is simply used to alert everyone that the official has acknowledged the play is dead by rule.
In the specific cases of fumbles or backward passes when incorrectly ruled down by contact or incomplete forward pass, respectively, Replay rules allow the ball to be awarded to the recovering team if that recovery is in the immediate continuing action.
When or if the whistle is sounded is completely irrelevant.
Cool. Now I understand. Thanks!

Logged
There are two kinds of people: those who say to God, 'Thy will be done,' and those to whom God says, 'All right, then, have it your way.'
You don't have a soul. You are a Soul. You have a body.
C.S. Lewis