I was a huge Pierce fan and in early 2000s would argue against the majority that wanted to dump him. Comparing him to Tatum is easy because they are both so good and do similar things. Pierce was a little better at finishing through contact although this year Tatum has closed the gap whereas Tatum has a nicer shot. Tatum’s length makes him a much more impactful defender. Tatum is more consistently good than Pierce who had a lot of off days especially before KG. Tatum is the best small forward ( partly due to injuries to all the great vets - Durant, Kawai, George ) in the game right now and Pierce never was. However, Pierce played in the golden age of wings with Kobe, TMac, Vince and a young Lebron.
As good as Pierce was, Tatum at age 24 could be playing in his 3rd ECF with a win today. When all is said and done it probably won’t even be worthy of a thread. We will be discussing where he falls next to Russell, Bird and Hondo.