Ugh, this topic continues to irk me. I know I should refrain from posting because it just bumps this to the top of the "latest discussions" board, but sometimes it can't be helped.
Will JT be better than PP? Maybe. JT's trajectory is certainly good.
Is JT at age 24 as good or better than PP? I think that's very debatable, and I'd probably lean "PP". You can show me all the stats you want about playoff games won, etc, but the reality is that PP was on crappy teams when he was younger. That's not a reflection on him.
To date, PP has the better record, and its not even close (1 NBA championship to 0 is... infinitely better).
Now, if the Celtics win a championship this year, we can resuscitate this thread. But until then, can we just put it to rest?