Hopefully we can all admit that we tend to place a higher value on players we have seen play repeatedly, against other players we are familiar with.
It's called bias, and everybody has it.
You don't want to develop reverse bias and go the other way either, but let's admit our nativist biases, hit the film room a little harder, and accept that Danny and his staff of professionals are going to have a lot more information on all these guys than we are.