. . . but he 's useless on both ends in transition, and tends to clog the lane on O while playing spotty D at best in the half-court.
I'm going to disagree on this point. The key to starting a fast break is rebounding, and Shaq would suddenly become the best rebounder on our team. He's also a very good passer.
I'll give you the rebounding of course, but I've never thought Shaq was unusually good at outlet passing, he seems a lot more adept at interior passes and kickouts. Might just be me not noticing though.
I guess it ultimately depends on what the terms wind up being. Vet min like others have said would be great; if we give up the chip of Sheed's contract and only get Shaq out of it, not as good.
He's the best center available for sure, but I worry about alpha dog issues. He won't be dealing with an up-and-coming superstar from a new generation, he'll be mostly surrounded by the guys he used to directly compete and measure himself against. I could see some friction there, and with Baby who's gonna want to put up good numbers, and who's apparently already bodyslammed Shaq once

I'd be happy to be wrong though.