I think Sharpe's ability to attack the rim is amazing. Did you know he has the all time combine record for vertical leap at 49".
I think Scoot is becoming a bust, I really do not care for him as he is a poor shooter, but sometimes in trades you have to take back a poison pill.
I'm the exact opposite. Have you watched the Blazers play much? I ask because I hadn't, and wanted to catch a few games because of Sharpe's stats (and to watch Holiday). And I found his stats do not match his play.
The games that I've seen, Sharpe is a negative on the court. His defense on ball is meh, off ball is poor. You cannot rely on him to create and have a good offense. You cannot rely on him to spot up and have a good offense. He's a guy that you can trust the advanced stats on - (105 off rating, 115 def rating).
Scoot has shifted his game a bit since his rookie year. He's more efficient. He's picking his spots better. He's always been able to create offense for his teammates. His shooting has continued to improve.
Scoot is not slouch athletically either, but he's also a competitor.
Of the two, I'd prefer Scoot as a "second draft" player. He could be karma for losing Billups all those years ago.