Maybe J-Dubb is more of an Andre Iguodala.
Yeah, Iggy is another guy in that poor man's Scottie Pippen mold. I rated Iggy as an All-Star caliber player during his prime. Similar to J-Dub. Iggy only made the ASG once which I thought was a crime. He deserved more ASG apperances.
Iggy was a better defender than J-Dub. Closer to Pippen. Iggy was also a very good ball-handler and passer. 5.4apg for his prime against 2.5 turnovers. A better rebounder than J-Dub as well. Sort of in between (in the middle) J-Dub and Pip as a rebounder.
What Iggy did not have was the scoring. He had some similar scoring seasons while in Philly but that was only when there were no other scoring options on team. Similar to Mikal Bridges in Brooklyn. Once Iggy had other scorers around him, his scoring numbers dropped. As a young player 9ppg and 12ppg next to Iverson. Towards the end in Philly, his scoring dropped to 14.1ppg and 12.4ppg. On a 50+ win team in Denver, it was 13ppg. On a 50+ win team in GSW, it 9.3ppg. After that Iggy accepted a bench role where his minutes and scoring dropped further (6-8ppg in 25-27mpg).
Iggy never had the scoring repertoire or scoring mentality of J-Dub (or Scottie Pippen who thought he was a better scorer than he was).
So I would rate Iggy even higher than J-Dub in non-scoring contributions and J-Dub higher than Iggy in scoring contributions. Overall, somewhat similar.
-----------
The problem with Iggy and scoring was both skill and mentality. The skill issue was the Iggy was a poor jump-shooter. He struggled to hit 40% of his 2pt midrange shots. J-Dub on the other hand is a very good midrange shooter (one of the better ones in the league) around the foul line area. His long 2pt jump-shooting is weak. And a weak 3pt shooter. He shoots 37.4% for his career but on only 3.5 attempts per game and that goes down in the playoffs (33.1%).
J-Dub on 10-16 feet jump-shots
2025-26 = 44-104 (only 33 games) = 42.3%
2024-25 = 147-279 = 52.7%
2023-24 = 102-194 = 52.6%
Iggy struggled with his 3pt, long 2pt, midrange 2pt. He scored efficiently in the paint on drives but his lack of a jump-shot left him without counters when the defenses cut off the paint. J-Dub has a counter in that midrange shot but is lacking in the outside shot (long two, 3pters) to have a full repertoire.