I wonder how many teams have never have a single legit top 5 player. How many times have the Lakers had 2 simultaneously?
A fun one to think about.
(1) Atlanta
They had a top 5 player back in St Louis with Bob Petitt. I don't think they have one since then. Dominique Wilkins has their best claim. He finished 2nd in MVP one year but I think that was a mistake by the voters. Never came close again. Then Dikembe Mutomo / Mookie Blaylock as their best players in late 90s. Joe Johnson and Al Horford as best players in 2000s / 10s. Trae Young as best player in 2020s. So for their 55 years in Atlanta since 1970, they have never had a top 5 player on their team.
(2) Charlotte
Alonzo Mourning, Larry Johnson, Glen Rice were their best players in the 90s. Alonzo reached top 5 player in late 90s with Miami but he wasn't top 5 in Charlotte. Neither were LJ or Rice. Nor Eddie Jones. Then Baron Davis and Mashburn. The team left for New Orleans after that. The Bobcats were the 2nd incarnation in Charlotte. They never had a top 5 player. Emeka Okafor was their best player. Then Jason Richardson / Stephen Jackson / Gerald Wallace. Al Jefferson. Then LaMelo Ball. So in 30 years or so, they have never had a top 5 player.
(3) Memphis
Pau Gasol was their best player. Then Z-Bo and Marc Gasol. Now Ja Morant. None were top 5 players.
(4) Seattle
A debatable one. Was Gary Payton ever a top 5 player in the league? I am not sure he was. Kemp wasn't. He was top 10 at his peak. Sikma, Gus Johnson and Dennis Johnson were never top 5 in the league in Seattle. Ray Allen. Nope. I don't think Seattle ever had a top 5 player despite all the success they managed to create up there. Spencer Haywood? Not sure he was ever top 5.
Teams with a Top 5 Player* Boston = Cousy, B Russell, Hondo, Cowens, Bird, McHale, KG, Tatum
* Cincinnati = Oscar Robertson
* Chicago = Jordan, Pippen, D-Rose?
* Cleveland = LeBron
* Dallas = Dirk, Doncic
* Denver = Jokic
* Detroit = Bob Lanier, Grant Hill
* Golden State = Wilt, R Barry, Steph, Durant
* Houston = Moses Malone, Olajuwon, Harden
* Indiana = Jermaine O'Neal
* Kansas City = Tiny Archibald
* LA Clippers = CP3, Kawhi?
* LA Lakers = Mikan, E Baylor, J West, Wilt, Kareem, Magic, Shaq, Kobe, LeBron, A Davis, Doncic
* Milwaukee = Kareem, Oscar Robertson, Marques Johnson (late 70s), Moncrief?, Giannis
* Minnesota = Garnett
* Miami = Zo, Wade, Shaq, LeBron
* New Jersey / Brooklyn = Kidd, Durant
* New York = W Reed, Walt Frazier, B King, Pat Ewing
* New Orleans = CP3, A Davis
* Oklahoma = Durant, Westbrook, SGA
* Orlando = Shaq, Penny, T-Mac, Dwight
* Philly = Wilt, Billy Cunningham?, Doc, Barkley, Iverson, Embiid
* Phoenix = Connie Hawkins, Westphal, Barkley, Nash
* Portland = B Walton, Drexler?
* Sacramento = Webber
* San Antonio = Gervin, D Robinson, T Duncan, Wemby (already? if not, he will be soon)
* Toronto = one year of Kawhi
* Utah = K Malone
* Washington = W Unseld, E Hayes, E Monroe?
LeadersBoston = 8 players
LA Lakers = 11 players
PHI = 5-6 players
MIL = 4-5 players
4 Top 5 players = GSW, MIA, NYK, ORL, PHX, SAS
3 Top 5 players = CHI, HOU, OKL
Orlando and Miami stand out as new(ish) franchises that have only existed for 35 years and already rate highly on this list. Orlando benefitting for draft luck with 3 #1 picks and then netting T-Mac in FA. Miami trading their way to 2 players, one top 5 pick in Wade and FA for LeBron. Hard work to get their guys except for LBJ.
Oklahoma also impressive. Only existed for a very short period. The year after Boston won the title in 2008. That was Durant's rookie year in Seattle. Then they moved. So 16-17 years. Something like that. And they have already had 3 top 5 players in Durant, Westbrook and SGA. They also had James Harden but refused to pay him. And PG13 had one big year there where he (unjustly IMO) got a top 5 MVP finish. Lady luck has shone brightly on them.
2 Top 5 Players = DAL, DET, LAC, NJN / BKN, NOH / NOP, POR, WAS
1 Top 5 Players = CLE, DEN, IND, MIN, SAC, TOR, UTA
Detroit is interesting because neither of their 2 title winning eras had top 5 players. Bob Lanier was in the 1970s when Detroit was the worst run team in the league and had little success. Grant Hill in the mid to late 90s when Detroit was often a middle of the pack of the squad with the exception of one strong year.
Indiana is also interesting. Reggie Miller was never a top 5 player. Jermaine O'Neal was a top 5 player for perhaps only 1 season in his career. Neither Danny Granger or Paul George were top 5 players. Tyrese Haliburton is not a top 5 player. So at best they had only 1 season in their near 40 year history with a top 5 player.
Toronto also noteworthy for their single season of Kawhi Leonard who led them to a title. They had Vince Carter and Chris Bosh as their other top players. DeMar DeRozan. They had T-Mac but lost him in FA.
The New Jersey Nets were always a famous example. They had Julius Erving in the ABA but lost him in the merger. Then never had a supstar again for almost 25 years when the got Kidd. And since Kidd left, they did not have a superstar since before leaving for Brooklyn and getting Durant.