I was great to see a good solid sample size of Maye. I was reassured, he looked good. It still appeared to me that the offense was being simplified, but that may be as much about the OL as the QB. Also, we have a bunch of really young receivers who probably are still digesting the more complex variations of the scheme.
It is still hard to judge how ready Maye is. He looked a lot more ready this game than what you were hearing from practice (and saw in the first preseason game). I am not sure how close to ready he is. I suspect that he would look a lot less ready if this had been a regular season game.
The OL is clearly not ready. I do not know how the OL readiness should impact the QB decision. If Maye is ready, should they hold him out because the OL is not ready? I am just not sure. My feeling is that once Maye is ready, he should play and not until. Defining ready may not be clear cut.
I agree with this. My take is, Brissett really hasn't shown much in any of the preseason games while Maye has, even accounting for only taking 6 snaps last week. I personally don't think they should start Brissett just because the O-Line is bad and he's more "experienced", if Maye has shown more he should get the job. And if we're being honest, how can we even be sure the O-Line next year is gonna be better? What if it's just as bad, should Maye sit another season then because of it? At some point he's gonna have to deal with taking hits, identifying blitzes and scrambling. Some of that comes from actually playing.
People bring up Mac Jones but the thing with Mac was, he had a high floor and low ceiling and I'd argue that's what he was. I don't think it would have made much of a difference if he sat a year behind Newton.
I don't exactly think the Pats have the luxury of sitting out a guy for a full year because instances of guys who have done it and succeeded either (a) had a great to elite QB already playing (Rodgers, Favre, Alex Smith, etc. and even Bledsoe was pretty good in 2001) or (b) weren't already coming off a hideous season. NE went 4-13 last season. If they start like 0-6 this year or something then believe me, fan backlash is gonna be at an all-time high especially if Brissett's starting and not doing well. It'd be one thing if Brissett did well but the whole team sucked but in that case, there'd still be calls rightaway for Maye to come in and I think even the Krafts would succumb to this pressure.
The tackle position is a joke though. Lowe, Okorafor. YUCK.
Truth be told, I'm not a Zappe fan but even Zappe has looked better than Brissett this preseason, and it's not like Brissett is lighting it up in training camp either. He started "steady" but has tailed off while Maye has shown improvement each week.