Drake Maye is 21 (22 on Aug 30). Joe Milton is 24 (25 in March). That 2.5 years makes a big difference. I was happy when the Pats took Milton in the 6th round (Pick 193, sound familiar). I took some flack for my posts on that, but why not take a chance on him. One preseason game, where Maye played what, 6 snaps, does not tell you anything about who is better. But it does tell you who is more NFL ready right now. I did not see the game (was driving and listened to much of it on the radio) but it seems that Milton looked good. Awesome. All you can say about Maye is that it is clear the coaching staff does not feel he is ready yet. Milton is probably fighting for a roster spot with Zappe. I would say this game was about that competition more than it was about Brissett vs. Maye.
I have been surprised to hear so much chatter about whether Maye should start day 1, start game x, or sit out the whole season, with no consideration at all to the reality of how ready Maye is. Right now, it does not appear that Maye is ready, is fully prepared to be a starting NFL QB. And I don't think he will be ready for the first game either. And there is no way to know if he will be ready by game 4 or game 6 or whatever. I think it is fair and smart to make sure he earns it, even regarding practice reps with the first team. Play him when he shows he is ready, not based on an arbitrary timeline. I don't believe that playing him before he is ready will get him ready any faster. There is a baseline he needs to be at before you put him out there. He is not at that baseline today, or so it appears.
Maye could be a bust, it happens to a lot of top QB picks. I was not expecting Maye to be ready right away so this does not concern me at this point. He may not play all season (as the starter) and even that will not concern me. If by the start of next season, he is still not any better than Jacoby Brissett, then you start to worry some. And if Milton gets to play along the way, and shows he is a legit NFL QB (like Garoppolo did), great.