Yes, I’d take any of the bigs I mentioned above over Embiid, and almost all of them over Jokic (who is a terrible defender, but a unique offensive player)..
A few words on Jokic's defense.
Postup defense
He's a big presence in the paint thanks to his length/strength. Allowed 0.71 PPP when posted up last season, which ranks in the 83.9th percentile.
Pick n Roll defense
Massively underrated PnR defender.
https://twitter.com/HPbasketball/status/1232719743657947137?s=20
''NBA Expert: Nikola Jokic Is The Best Pick And Roll Defender In The League''
https://fadeawayworld.net/2020/02/27/nba-expert-nikola-jokic-is-the-best-pick-and-roll-defender-in-the-league/
Rim protection
I'm just gonna repost Somebody's stats.
''When Jokic is on the floor, the Nuggets allow 3.8 percent fewer shots at the rim than average. That ranks in the 93rd percentile among all NBA players''
- Joel Embiid - 100th percentile (Minus-7.9 percent)
- Bam Adebayo - 98th percentile (Minus-5.5 percent)
- Draymond Green - 95th percentile (Minus-4.7 percent)
- Kristaps Porzingis - 95th percentile (Minus-4.5 percent)
- Nikola Jokic - 93rd percentile (Minus-3.9 percent)
Perimeter defense
This is his weak spot. He ain't quick enough to stay in front of explosive players on the perimeter. That being said, the vast majority of Centers in our draft are old school players. I can't think of a single Center that would be a matchup problem for Jokic on the perimeter. Imo, the best 2-way mobile Center in the draft is Bam, but he ain't a 3pt shooter. No need for Jokic to follow him on the perimeter.
I challenge anybody to name a Center in our draft that would be a matchup problem for Jokic on the perimeter. At the same time, Jokic would be a matchup problem for literally every single Center in the draft on the offensive side of the ball.
Those numbers regarding his PnR defence are from the RS, they looked terrible against the Jazz in the playoffs. Both sides of the extreme (his RS/Jazz numbers) shouldn't be taken as gospel when evaluating his PnR defence imo: he has his issues in defending the PnR due to his weak lateral agility and explosiveness, but his quick hands, great anticipation and good positioning offset those weaknesses quite a bit. He's really an average to slightly above average defender depending on the matchup - nowhere close to being a terrible one, but he's definitely not elite either.
It's very easy to hide him on D, cause he's a very good defender when used in a drop scheme. In fact, only 4% of the plays he defended in the playoffs where PnR plays. I would argue that Jokic is a very good PnR defender, provided that he's used in a drop scheme. We had more or less the same discussion when I drafted him.
There are 3 ways to defend the pick n roll:
1. go under the pick
2. go over the pick
3. switch (This is what the Celtics do whenever Theis is on the court.)
How do the Nuggets defend the PnR?
- Switching is off the table cause Jokic ain't quick enough to stay in front of guards on the perimeter.
- Going under the pick is a great option against ball handlers who are below average 3pt shooters. Obviously, it ain't a viable option against ball handlers who are good shooters.
- That leaves them with the 2nd option: go over the pick. Their guard defender denies the open 3pt shot. At the same time, Jokic drops back to protect the rim in case the opposing ball handler passes the ball to the roller. It's a perfectly viable defensive scheme. In fact, the Nuggets allowed 0.84 PPP when defending the PnR ball handler last season (7th best in the league). Just because the C's switch, it doesn't mean that all teams should do the same thing. Fwiw, the C's allowed 0.86 PPP (8th in the league).
Again, none of this really matters in our league, cause the vast majority of big men are old school players. In our league, Jokic has zero weaknesses. Imo, he's the best Center in the draft. Based on the advanced stats, it's not even close.
VORP by position - Centers (career high in a single season)
1. Nikola Jokic 7.0
2. Moses Malone 5.5
Box Plus/Minus by position - Centers (career high in a single season)
1. Nikola Jokic 9.1
2. Arvydas Sabonis 6.7
(...)
7. Moses Malone 4.5
Obviously, he ain't got the accolades of Moses, but he's only 25 years old. Jokic led a mediocre Nuggets team to the WCF last season (alongside Murray). When all is said and done, I firmly believe he'll be considered a better player than Moses. Imo, he's already a top 2 passing Center of all time. Only passing Center I'd take over Jokic is Arvydas Sabonis in his prime. For the record, I believe that prime Sabonis was a GOAT candidate! Unfortunately, his prime was cut short because of injuries.