Great thread, TP for the OP.
There's no overrated celticbloggers, we have great posters and terrible posters, but nobody overrates them/us/you... I laughed out loud, and I really needed that today. Thanks.
About players overrated by this blog, there are quite a few, we tend to overrate our own players, but on the other hand we have the ones who get bashed: TA, Jeff Green, Bass and Rondo come off the top of my head.
And yeah, the "grass is greener" effect works with players from time to time. Omer Asik was overrated by a good number of people here, who were willing to send one and even two first round picks to Morey for the right to pay Asik a lot of money. Omer Asik is worse than pre-ACL injury Perk, his only ability is having enough athleticism to make him a decent defender for such a big guy. But his offensive game is just terrible.
I'm happy Danny didn't help Morey out of his "genius backloaded contracts" to Lin and Asik, and I hope we can get a better C in this year's draft.
Other overrated guys: Greg Stiemsma, Allan Ray, Shavlick Randolph, Kevinn Pinkney, and my binky Terrence Williams