Except ... doesn't that pretty much describe Paul's situation way back when as well?
While Pierce had his moments, he was considerably less antagonizing with the media, and less abrasive in general.
Ultimately, being a team captain is about how the _team_ sees you, not the fans or media. And a young team can definitely benefit from internal leadership. There seems to be pretty strong indication that the players follow Rondo's lead naturally.
No, ultimately it's about whose model of behavior you like your young team to follow.
Let me clarify, my use of the word _team_ here would include the coach & staff, not just the players.
And no, you can't just pick someone and expect players to follow just because you picked them. A leader isn't so just because he is a perfect model of what you might want.
Certainly an organization would not want to pick the pied piper who will lead his players over the cliff. But I doubt the Celtics see Rondo as that at all.
I think the organization probably knows Rondo pretty darn well. A hell of a lot better than fans & media know him.
For example, even if Josh Beckett was seen as a nice locker room guy and all, I wouldn't exactly want the team to mimic him... especially after he pretty much flat out stated that baseball just isn't that important for him anymore.
I don't remember the Red Sox ever ripping that "C" off Jason Varitek's chest and stitching it onto Beckett's uniform. So I'm not really sure how that's really relevant other than for shock value ("Oooh! I remember that nasty ol' beer-drinkin', chicken-eating Beckett!").
Are you saying that you think that Rondo & Beckett are comparable personalities? How well do you know these fellows?