How many players in their 20's ever got to play with similar team mates like KG, Pierce and Ray Allen in a situation like Rondo's?
I'd guess a lot more than you think. But are you talking about 2008 big three or the fringe all-stars of the last few years?
Has there ever been an All Star point guard that's as poor a shooter as Rondo from the FT line and 3 point line?
Possibly not. But a 4-time all-star he is. He made those all-star games because of his overall level of play, where he does many things well enough that he's still one of the top guards in the league in spite of his shooting. It's not like he made 1 team as a fluke selection.
I think a better question is, how many point guards have there been that would have been regular all-stars if they shot (and hit free throws) like Rondo? How many point guards would be regular all-stars if they never scored more than 14 ppg?
It's true that he's not a great shooter. It's also true that he's been one of the best point guards in the league for a while. It's useful to notice what he does poorly, it's equally useful to notice what he does well and how well he does those things.
I know what he does well. Just trying to provide perspective because sometimes I wonder if you notice the things he doesn't do well.
I also take into consideration that he's had the rare fortune of playing with All star caliber players up until the 2011 to 2012 seasons. He's obviously improved as ours original big 3 started to drastically decline. I'm not questioning his 'his play', because he made the most of the situation he was in. I just think it's obvious that without those excellent/elite shooters around him, and his lack of shooting ability - that people will question how much their absence will affect his ability to put up numbers, particularly on the assists side of the equation. (The strongest part of his game and the one above all other skills placing to All Star level talent).
In the interest of perspective, take a look at the "Qualified" leaders in fg% for 2013 on espn.com. PP was 12th among small forwards, KG was 13th among power forwards, Bass would be 16th among power forwards and Bradley would be 24th (last) among shooting guards. Those are the excellent/elite shooters around Rondo, and he led the league in assists by a decent margin.
People used to talk about how much Rondo depended on Ray's shooting, that was clearly nonsense. People talk about how much Rondo is dependent on PP and KG, but as they waned as players Rondo became more productive, not less. Why didn't we see him struggle more as their play worsened?
Look at the team this year. Rondo's not playing well at all. He's integrating himself into the team, and hasn't built up much chemistry with his teammates yet. His team is 26th in the league in fg%, so clearly he's not even surrounded by good shooters. There are only two players in the league averaging better than 1 assist per36 more than Rondo.
If Rondo was playing as many minutes now as he was last year he'd be just over 2 assists/game lower than last year. He'd be .5 apg out of 2nd place in the league. You're claiming that Rondo would struggle to get assists without PP and KG. Is 9 assists/game "struggling to get assists"? If so, that would be where he is now, assuming he was playing equal minutes.
What happens to Rondo's assist totals as he becomes healthier? What happens to his assist totals when he and his teammates get used to each other and they get in sync with his passes? What happens to his assist totals if his poor shooting teammates are upgraded to average or a little better than average shooters? I'd say all of these things will push the numbers up. Would you agree?
If Rondo gets healthier (he will) and develops better chemistry with his teammates (he will) and, over time, the team gets somewhat better shooters (we all hope and pray that they will) then his assist totals will very likely go up. But his assist rate isn't that much lower than it was in the past even now.
So where's the big dropoff in assists that Rondo will surely experience without KG and PP? You claim to know what Rondo does well. But if you were expecting a big drop in his assists without KG and PP I'd say that you really don't, or at least how well he does those things. It could turn out that you're right, that Rondo's assist rate will stay the same or worsen as Rondo gets healthier and more in sync with his teammates and we get better shooters. But I wouldn't bet the farm on it.
You're claiming that Rondo would struggle to get assists without PP and KG. Is 9 assists/game "struggling to get assists"? If so, that would be where he is now, assuming he was playing equal minutes.
I never claimed that he'd struggle. I merely pointed out that his detractors would say that he's unproven without Pierce and KG and his assists numbers were helped by their great shooting, and the Celtics overall excellent jumpshooting. Particularly without KG who has been an
elite jump shooter for Rondo's entire tenure as an All Star point guard.
In the interest of perspective, take a look at the "Qualified" leaders in fg% for 2013 on espn.com. PP was 12th among small forwards, KG was 13th among power forwards, Bass would be 16th among power forwards and Bradley would be 24th (last) among shooting guards. Those are the excellent/elite shooters around Rondo, and he led the league in assists by a decent margin.
Tim I know you'll defend Rondo no matter what the debate. Unfortunately you're using FG% to try and argue that he hasn't been surrounded by elite jumpshooters for his entire career since 2007-2008. This is simply wrong.
Now the argument here isn't that he's not one of the best passers in the league- because he clearly is. The argument is that his stats benefit from having these sharpshooters around him. Now that he doesn't have these guys, he's going to lose those few extra assists that shooters like KG, Paul and Ray gave him- where other elite point guards may not have that luxury.
Lets look at 2011-12 when KG and Pierce were starting to decline.
NBA assist totals 2011-12 per 40 minutesAssists per game in different locations on the floor:At the rim:Assists made directly at the basket
(dunks, layups, tip ins)Nash 6.0
Rondo 4.5
Rubio 4.1
Calderon 4.1
He's 2nd in the league in 'At the rim'. Now he's got KG at number 7 in the league at 'At the rim' FG percentage, and he's also got Bass at number 17- so he's doing well finding these alley oops and layup passes. Avery Bradley contributed to this with his back door cuts and slashing, and Rondo did well to find him for those easy buckets. Bradley had an 'At the rim' % of 65%, and 64% of those 'At the rim' buckets were assisted baskets.
BUT- Kevin Garnett has the number one percentage of assisted buckets at the rim in 2012, with over 80% of those baskets coming from an assist.Again, Rondo has always done a great job finding KG, but KG has always been a master of getting above the rim even in his old age and using his length and reach to facilitate those lobs and alley oops.
With KG gone, where do these 4.5 'At the rim' assists come from per game?Lets look at the jumpshooting- where you seem to mock my claim that the Celtics are an 'elite' jumpshooting team.
Assists leading to baskets 10 feet or under per 40 minutes (excluding directly at the rim as listed above)1)Nash 1.4
2)Calderon 1.0
3)Chris Paul 0.9
4)Tony Parker 0.8
5)Jarret Jack 0.7
6)Mike Conley Jr 0.7
7)Darren Collison...0.7
go down to number 24.. Rajon Rondo at 0.3
Not much action here, although KG was the 2nd best power forward in the NBA from 3-9 feet and 51% of his made baskets were from assists. Bass was a very poor here due to his lack of post game- he'd either shoot a jumper or drive to dunk. He did have 43% of his shots here come from assists, but shot only 25% from the floor at 3-9 feet.
Now here's where it starts to get interesting, and here's where Rondo's critics will point out how good his team actually was at converting his potential assists into made baskets. Further below I'll post the actual shooting stats of his team mates compared to the rest of the league.Mid range jumpshots 10-15 feet per 40 minutesAssists leading to made baskets between 10-15 feet of the rim
1)Rondo 1.12)Williams 0.9
3)Rose 0.8
4)Jack 0.8
5)Holiday 0.8
6)Conley Jr 0.8
7)Calderon 0.7
Nash 0.79)Lowry 0.5
10)Jennings 0.4 11)Parker 0.4 12) Lawson 0.4 13) Knight 0.3 14)
Chris Paul 0.3 Long jumpshots 16-23 feet per 40 minutes Assists leading to made baskets 16-23 feet from the basket.1)Rajon Rondo 4.12)Rose 3.0
3)Nash 2.8
4)Calderon 2.6
5)Jack 2.5
6)Lowry 2.2
3 point shots per 40 minutesAssists leading to made 3 point baskets
1)Nelson 3.3
2)Rubio 3.2
3)Williams 3.0
4)Parker 3.0
5)Paul 2.8
6)Rondo 2.77)Nash 2.7
You can see that shots taken from between 10-15 feet and 16-23 feet, Rondo has an average of 2.4 more assists per game than ANYONE in the rest of the league in 2012.Why is that?Well, if we look at his team mates shooting efficiencies compared to the rest of the NBA at their position you can see he was
SPOILED with help.
NBA power forwards shot attempts 3-9 feet from basketIn order of shooting %
1)Aldridge
2)Garnett
3)Gasol
4)Griffin
5)Love
6)Millsap
KG= second in the NBA.
NBA power forwards mid range jumpshot shot attempts 10-15 feet from basket1)Bosh
2)Bass3)Lee
4)Scola
5)Gasol
6)Nowitzki
7)Aldridge
8)GarnettBrandon Bass is the second best shooter from 10-15 feet out of NBA power forwards and KG is number 8.If you look at the percentage of assisted baskets in this 10-15 feet range, you'll find Bass at number 3 in the NBA, and KG at number 7. In other words, the Celtics/Rondo should get credit for finding Bass and KG for their preferred shot, but Bass and KG were also ELITE jumpshooters from the power forward position- They were both in the top 316-23 feet jumpshots by NBA power forwards 2011-12 Guess who the number 2 and 3 power forwards in the NBA were from 16-23 feet.
I'll give you 2 guesses.1)Nowitzki 50%
2)Bass 48%
3)Kevin Garnett 48%
4)Scola 44%
5)Aldridge 43%
6)Gasol 43%
How many of these jumpshots from 16-23 feet were 'assisted baskets'? - in other words....
Who are the leaders at the power forward position in 2011-12 as catch and shoot or catch and one dribble jumpshooters from 16-23 feet from the basket?1)Brandon Bass 95%2)Jamison 94.7%
3)Anderson 94%
4)Scola 90%
5)Garnett 89%6)Gasol 86.1%
So those are the power forwards.
Is it safe to say Rondo was passing to elite jumpshooters Tim?
For arguments sake,
Lets look at Paul Pierce and his jumpshooting in 2011-12 compared to the rest of the NBA's small forwards...
NBA Small forwards mid range jumpshot shot attempts 10-15 feet from basket1)Iguoadala
2)James
3)Gay
4)Anthony
5)Pierce6)Durant
Yes, Pierce was better from 10-15 feet in 2011-12 than Kevin Durant. He was ELITE.
Guess what he was from 10-15 feet in 2013 when Rondo was injured for half a season? 2nd in the league behind durant.
From 16-23 feet he was 6th.If you look at how many of those jumpshots were 'assisted' in 2011-12, Pierce comes in above all of the other top 6 small forwards at 37.2%- even though he's an incredible spot up shooter who can drain it off the dribble, he's also just as good, if not better on the catch and shoot. His 'assisted' ranking is number 6 overall. Rondo gets an assist on the board everytime Pierce catches that pass and drains it. I wonder how he'll fair with Gerald Wallace or even Jeff Green catching that pass instead?
Note that even without Rondo for half a season in 2013, Pierce still had an assisted rate of 38.1%, even higher than 2011-12...
Moving on to...
Long jumpshots 16-23 feet and 3 point baskets by NBA Small forwards per 40 minutes*Pierce was the 12th best small forward from 16-23 feet.
*He was the 7th best three point shooter.
Now Rondo's been back for 6 games and he's averaging 8.4 assists per 36 minutes. That's 2.2 assists less per game than last season and 3 less assists per game than 2011-12. I won't judge him on anything at the moment because he's recovering.
But the whole argument is that without KG and Pierce and having an elite jumpshooting team around him, he may not be an All Star caliber player.
If he comes back next season, after this off season to further recover/rehab his knee, is he still an All Star with a stat line like 9 assists, 13 points and 6 rebounds a game?
You're saying 'we'll just put better shooters around him', which is basically saying that for Rondo to be an All Star, he may need elite shooters around him.
The critics argument:
*Rondo can't shoot from the line- true
*He can't shoot threes-true
*He's coming of an ACL injury and his return to former athletic range/ability is not certain- true
*He's lost one of the best big men in the NBA in Garnett- more importantly, he's lost one of the best shooters in the NBA at their position.- true
* He's lost one of the best small forwards in the NBA, more importantly- one of the best jumpshooters and three point shooters in the NBA for his position.
*He still has Bass, but Bass doesn't have KG to stretch the floor, and Bass is looking like he'll be traded before he and Rondo get time to play together whilst Rondo's even 75% of his former self.- true?
That being said, he's still...
*arguably the best passer in the NBA
*one of the most competitive players in the NBA
*got championship experience
*has huge value in attracting potential free agents due to his game being based around 'sharing' and getting the ball to players at their spot.
*arguably has the best court vision of anyone- or is in the 1% category of Chris Paul and Steve Nash in this segment.
*Arguably has the best anticipation in the NBA and uses this gift to give his team mates better shots- particularly on the break.
Anyway, hopefully this gives you another perspective as to why he might not be all we hoped he may be without Pierce and KG.
Just so we are clear...
In 2012 the Celtics were the 15th best team from directly 'at the rim' basket percentage with 63%. They were 26th in the league from 3-9 feet with 33%.
Yet they somehow took the Heat to 7 games in the Eastern Conference finals. How did they accomplish this?
By being the number 1 jumpshooting team from 10-15 feet and 16-23 feet. They also had the highest number of assisted field goals from those distances of all teams in the NBA. http://www.hoopdata.com/teamshotlocs.aspx?yr=2012&type=pg