How many players in their 20's ever got to play with similar team mates like KG, Pierce and Ray Allen in a situation like Rondo's?
I'd guess a lot more than you think. But are you talking about 2008 big three or the fringe all-stars of the last few years?
Has there ever been an All Star point guard that's as poor a shooter as Rondo from the FT line and 3 point line?
Possibly not. But a 4-time all-star he is. He made those all-star games because of his overall level of play, where he does many things well enough that he's still one of the top guards in the league in spite of his shooting. It's not like he made 1 team as a fluke selection.
I think a better question is, how many point guards have there been that would have been regular all-stars if they shot (and hit free throws) like Rondo? How many point guards would be regular all-stars if they never scored more than 14 ppg?
It's true that he's not a great shooter. It's also true that he's been one of the best point guards in the league for a while. It's useful to notice what he does poorly, it's equally useful to notice what he does well and how well he does those things.
I know what he does well. Just trying to provide perspective because sometimes I wonder if you notice the things he doesn't do well.
I also take into consideration that he's had the rare fortune of playing with All star caliber players up until the 2011 to 2012 seasons. He's obviously improved as ours original big 3 started to drastically decline. I'm not questioning his 'his play', because he made the most of the situation he was in. I just think it's obvious that without those excellent/elite shooters around him, and his lack of shooting ability - that people will question how much their absence will affect his ability to put up numbers, particularly on the assists side of the equation. (The strongest part of his game and the one above all other skills placing to All Star level talent).
In the interest of perspective, take a look at the "Qualified" leaders in fg% for 2013 on espn.com. PP was 12th among small forwards, KG was 13th among power forwards, Bass would be 16th among power forwards and Bradley would be 24th (last) among shooting guards. Those are the excellent/elite shooters around Rondo, and he led the league in assists by a decent margin.
People used to talk about how much Rondo depended on Ray's shooting, that was clearly nonsense. People talk about how much Rondo is dependent on PP and KG, but as they waned as players Rondo became more productive, not less. Why didn't we see him struggle more as their play worsened?
Look at the team this year. Rondo's not playing well at all. He's integrating himself into the team, and hasn't built up much chemistry with his teammates yet. His team is 26th in the league in fg%, so clearly he's not even surrounded by good shooters. There are only two players in the league averaging better than 1 assist per36 more than Rondo.
If Rondo was playing as many minutes now as he was last year he'd be just over 2 assists/game lower than last year. He'd be .5 apg out of 2nd place in the league. You're claiming that Rondo would struggle to get assists without PP and KG. Is 9 assists/game "struggling to get assists"? If so, that would be where he is now, assuming he was playing equal minutes.
What happens to Rondo's assist totals as he becomes healthier? What happens to his assist totals when he and his teammates get used to each other and they get in sync with his passes? What happens to his assist totals if his poor shooting teammates are upgraded to average or a little better than average shooters? I'd say all of these things will push the numbers up. Would you agree?
If Rondo gets healthier (he will) and develops better chemistry with his teammates (he will) and, over time, the team gets somewhat better shooters (we all hope and pray that they will) then his assist totals will very likely go up. But his assist rate isn't that much lower than it was in the past even now.
So where's the big dropoff in assists that Rondo will surely experience without KG and PP? You claim to know what Rondo does well. But if you were expecting a big drop in his assists without KG and PP I'd say that you really don't, or at least how well he does those things. It could turn out that you're right, that Rondo's assist rate will stay the same or worsen as Rondo gets healthier and more in sync with his teammates and we get better shooters. But I wouldn't bet the farm on it.