I'm not sure about making Big Al a power forward, but I do like Gortat.
What I worry about is having too big men, neither of whom is tremendously mobile. The idea of Big Al chasing around guys on the perimeter makes scares me.
To me it's the lesser of two evils. If you keep Al at center, that's a huge defensive hole for teams to exploit down low. I'd rather force the opposing team to go small ball with Gortat as the last line of defense, rather than having Jefferson as my last line of defense.
I disagree. Having two stationary big men is almost conceding any chance of playoff success against teams with mobile front lines.
As I said earlier, if the 2010 Celtics made Shaq look good at defense, then Big Al can look fine as a defensive center. You just need to commit to a strong, mobile defensive power forward, and have some good defensive wings. A team like that can beat anybody. Gortat / Big Al, on the other hand, just creates problems and question marks.
I think BATF should look for a trade to bring a bit better balance. He's got two nice players who would play horribly next to one another.