The closer I look at Sully's advanced stats from last year, the more I'm thinking I might have underrated his potential. The kid might be a starter some day. I'd hang onto him unless we can get an obvious upgrade.
Millsap is obviously better than any PF we currently have on our team (aside from KG... who we're forcing to play Center). He's undersized, but he's a quality defender. Utah has a plethora of quality bigs. Millsap, Big Al, Favors and Kanter. Favors and Kanter are the future of that team. Favors is a future star. Big Al is already an all-star. So there's only so many minutes...
Favors had the highest defensive rating on that team, but Millsap was 2nd. You figure having to feed minutes to so many bigs is part of the reason Millsap only averaged 30 minutes. He actually has the highest "win shares per 48 minutes" on the team.
If you look at his stats per 36 minutes they were:
17 points, 8.5 rebounds, 3 assists, 1.5 steals, 1.2 blocks 49% shooting
Quality player. Are we talking about trading for him or is the idea that we can sign him with the MLE? If you're not looking at advanced stats, it's hard to rationalize giving big money to a guy who on paper looks like he averages 14 points, 7 rebounds... and is only 6'8 245 pounds.