Ronda's our best player (in terms of talent), but KG has always been the most important (leadership).
I'd say in terms of "talent", Pierce is unmatched on this squad. Guy can do it all. But big men win you titles in this league and defense is gold. KG is the epicenter of our defense and his impact is unparalleled on Boston.
Rondo has skill. He's also flawed. He's not the most talented player, the best player, or the most important player on the Celtics. He's really good, though.
I think you're selling Rondo short there.
I agree that Pierce is still a great all-around player (and it's incredible that he can still do it at his age), but Rondo's really improved as a player, too. Teams used to dare him to shoot, and this year he finally started to make them pay for it. If he can stretch that range to the three-point line, driving the lane (his favorite move, especially for kicking it out for open shots) just became so much easier.
Definitely agree on KG's importance. I was talking to my buddy about a week ago, and he and I were arguing about whether Chris Paul or KG was a bigger "culture-changer." His argument was based around the fact that the Clippers were always the laughing stock of the league, and now they're making their second straight playoff appearance, on their way to a fifty-win season, and have one of the top teams for the future, and it's all really because of Paul.
Obviously, I disagreed. I argued that pre-KG, Boston was coming off an abysmal season, highlighted by a 24-game losing streak, and once the Ticket arrived, he turned a 24-win team in a 66-win team that won a title. In one freaking year. Obviously, we had more talent than LA has now, but it cannot be forgotten how KG made guys care about defense, and more importantly, each other.
Man, KG is really special. Love the guy.