Bulls send: Jeremy Lin, Kenneth Faried
Cavs send: Jrue Holiday, Thad Young
Excellent trade for IP.
I can understand moving Holiday for a high usage offensive creator like Jeremy Lin for Cleveland. If you have to give up Thad Young for Faried to make this deal (I know that is not what happened), then so be it.
I think Holiday and Lin, in terms of potential / ceiling, are pretty similar but offer totally different skill-sets. Lin as the high usage offensive creator vs Holiday's less offensive punch, more defense. Given how limited Cleveland is offensivelyand given how they are planning for 3+ years time rather than next season, I can see the appeal in Lin over Jrue.
In the immediate sense, Jrue Holiday is the better basketball over Lin and is a far far superior fit in Chicago's roster than Lin. So this is a really nice upgrade for IP.
------------------------------------------
I also prefer Thaddeus Young over Faried. I think that is a good improvement for IP too.
Faried = if you can't do a darn thing offensively except make layups (garbage man) then you [dang] well better be an
elite defender and rebounder. That is the only way you are going to be a quality starting PF in the NBA and Faried isn't a high level defender. And he isn't a starting quality PF. Nor is he a high level backup.
Faried is a one dimensional player that has no business starting in the NBA (or being anything more than a 15-20mpg backup) until he either develops his offense or improves his defense.
Thaddeus Young is a weak starter, a very weak starter in this 24 team CB League, but he is a high level backup PF (who can play 26-30mpg) because his skill-set as an undersized quick PF creates matchup advantages for his team. He enables his teammates on both ends of the court. Faried hurts his teammates on one end of the court and doesn't do enough to make up for it elsewhere to be a high minute player.
----------------------------------------------
Just look at all the difficulties Denver had with him. Couldn't play Faried alongside Koufos/Mozgov/McGee without wrecking your offense. Can't play him alongside Al Harrington without wrecking your defense.
He is a difficult player to work with.
His skill-set is not easy to build a functioning team around. He just doesn't work well enough with a very large number of players.