If Doc wants him out of the game then he should put someone else in. Rondo's a warrior, he's going to do what he can to help the team win. I don't see the point in attacking Rondo for trying to fight through an injury.
Exactly. Doc should take him out of the game when he goes into "tired mode."
His ball denial defense is about as good as you'll see from a point guard. He doesn't always stick with his man but he's also very disruptive to opposing offenses when he cheats off his man to help out.
All subjective. And even you admit "he doesn't always stick with his man." But a lot of time it's not to double-team someone else. It's just to stand and watch. And sometimes to watch his man hit a three.
From synergysports, when Rondo's opponent isolates him, that player scores about .58ppp, compared to .78 for Bradley or (ahem) 1.12 for West. .58ppp is fairly smothering defense.
Again, this is just in iso situations where you use this stat. Rondo let's himself get picked so easily that it's no longer an iso situation. Also, Bradley is usually covering the team's best guard so of course he's going to have more points scored against him. Doc puts Rondo on the other team's weakest offensive player much of the time. Or the one least likely to drive. Guys who just like to shoot spot-up threes (like Novak).
Again, you talk about watching games, but it's fairly rare that people playing against Rondo have big games, and the players he guards seem to score a lot of their points when Rondo is either out of the game or covering someone else.
Ahem, have you ever seen what Derrick Rose, Chris Paul, and Russell Westbrook do to Rondo when he tries to cover them? BIG GAMES! But like I said, most times Doc realizes this and puts Rondo on the shooting guards for these teams. Just like he had Rondo on Novak last night.
You talk about people being blind, but the case is your viewing is very selective. If Rondo's man scores because Rondo wasn't playing great defense, you take notice. If that man goes the next 7-8 possessions without doing a thing, it's like those plays never happened.
When Rondo's man doesn't score the next 7-8 possessions it's not always because he is playing "good defense." It's because they were able to drive and dish. But whatever, that's such an anecdotal thing to say. You don't show specifics with that statement. Just what you think you remember.
I'm talking about two specific plays last night, and asked folks to watch for these types of plays in future games, where Rondo just laid down and gave up. And it wasn't because he was injured. He was running around on offense and on other defensive possessions. Here he just quit. I don't see Paul Pierce doing that. Or Bradley. Or KG. Or Ray. They don't just stand there and point like Rondo's prima donna self "ooh, oooh, my man is running free."
He wasn't even picked at all on that last Novak three. Chandler was three feet away from him. Rondo actually ran into Chandler well after Novak was at the three point line to make it look like he got picked.
Weak.