I agree with the sentiment Nick, but I will say that I've found 2k to be a pretty decent tool to see how certain lineups work and how players would mesh. Obviously, it's not flawless but it's an advanced enough game where I do think it presents value here.
But ya, I would definitely use my own eyes over its rankings though. I don't understand advanced stats - not that I don't think it's valuable, I just don't care enough to look into them - so I can't rally speak for that.