. . . Wayne Ellington, who was awful last year
How was Ellington "awful"? He was an elite 3PT shooter, he was a good defender, and he showed excellent fundamentals and instincts. His Per-36 numbers are all about average for a SG.
I'm guessing you didn't watch Ellington play much last year*. He was one of the pleasant surprises of the draft, putting up pretty good production for the 28th overall pick.
* (although, frankly, the harshness of your tone aimed against Edgar suggests that your analysis may be personal, rather than objective. I mean, your entire critique of Edgar's team was one giant attack, starting with "Okay, Toronto, it's pretty obvious you took the philosophy that drafting deep in the draft you didn't think you could put together a true contending team . . ." I don't think it's exactly fair to put words in Edgar's mouth.)
I believe you are mistaking harshness of tone for reality of the situation Roy. Edgar's entire post was hype and hyberbole and, let's be fair here, it's pretty obvious what the strategy was. I didn't put words in Edgar's mouth, I simply gave my opinion on what their team building strategy was. Given his advertisement of having so many Celtics, I don't think I'm wrong.
Second let's remember who challenged people who didn't believe in his team first. That was Edgar when he said
If you want to say Perkins is hurt and all of that dirty stuff
be our guest
This team have enough bodies to wait half a season and become champs
after that.Is everyone just supposed to hang back and just say "Yeah, you're right Edgar, we won't bring up your severely hurt starting center and just hand you the trophy now."
I apologize if you or anyone reads the wrong tone into my critique of Toronto. It wasn't an attack. It was what I believe to be a much more realistic look at his team then Edgar is portraying.
Also regarding Ellington, I think he's awful because of his 9.6 PER, his 52% TS% even though apparently he's an elite three point shooter and good FT shooter, his defensive rating being 14 points higher than his offensive rating and his 1 assist to 1 turnover ratio.
I saw Ellington play four times last year and was thoroughly unimpressed each time, which is disappointing given that I thought he would be a steal in the draft being taken that late. He still could be. He didn't have a good rookie season at all but he could still turn into a heck of a player taken that late.