I think we would need a two guard with size coming back in any Ray Allen deal. Either that or a true SF, assuming PP can slide to the two guard. Just don't want a smallish players trying to match up against the good teams.
I don't think size is the problem with Hinrich. Hinrich is a very good defender, and can cover bigger guys very well. The problem is offensively, he is not suited to be a real scorer, and that is what they need from that spot. It would put a lot more pressure on Pierce and Rondo to score, if they had to rely on Hinrich as the starting SG.
I think it would be worth it if they could get Thomas back as well, but they would then be better off looking for a more pure scorer/shooter to take the starting SG spot, allowing Hinrich to come off the bench.
I don't know , I think Hinrich could fit in with the starting 5 on offense. He is a career 38% 3pt shooter so he would still give us the ability to spread the floor. It would also give us 2 PG's on the floor at times with Rondo and Hinrich being able to create shots for others with their ball handling and passing ability. Add that to his ability to be a much better man on man defender and I don't think there would be that much difference at all, plus he can run the 2nd unit at times along with Daniels.
Well, it depends if the C's are willing to adjust their offensive system. Perhaps it would be a good thing to have a SG who they are not relying on as much. Right now, their offense relies on Ray (and House) running off screens and launching shots. That is not Hinrich's game. While he is a decent shooter, he is not a primary scorer type.
So if the C's are willing to change their offense, to have more overall movement, and if Rondo can take a bigger role as a scorer, than it could be OK.
But I really think Hinrich is at his best when he is allowed to be a distributor, who takes the occasional, wide open shot, and then locks down on defense. To have him in a different role, you will decrease his effectiveness and value.