Fantasy Football Feedback

[Lucky17]

Pick 2:

Maurice Jones-Drew
Willis McGahee
Edgerrin  James
Justin Fargas

Hmmm.

Mojo and JAX at home vs. Buffalo
McGahee and BAL at Houston
Edge and ARZ at home vs. Miami
Fargas and OAK at KC

I'll say Mojo and Edge? Fargas is definitely the worst of the 4.

Wait, is this for our league, Hobbs? You should definitely start Fargas. He's due.

[steve]

Would you trade McNabb for R. Grant and Heinze Ward?

[Lucky17]

You're trading McNabb? Who's your backup QB?

In a vacuum, I say no. I think McNabb has a tremendous year this year. Grant is already dealing with a sore hammy, I believe; will he hold up for the year? (I hope so, he's on one of my teams.)

[crownsy]

Would you trade McNabb for R. Grant and Heinze Ward?

wouldn't consdier it until i knwo the extent of that ham string injury. Those have a way of lingering on RB's.

If he is close to 100%, then it depends on who's stepping in for you at QB with mcnabb gone. IF its an upper-mid tier guy, probley, grants going to be good and ward is often the focus of big bens red zone tosses. if its tavaris jackson or something, then no way.

[crownsy]

haha TP lucky, we pretty much posted the exact same thing

[steve]

It's Warner.

I lost Colston at WR as well.  

I'd be taking a chance on Grant becoming healthy, any Greenbay fans out there, might know how severe it is?

[Lucky17]

It's Warner.

I lost Colston at WR as well. 

I'd be taking a chance on Grant becoming healthy, any Greenbay fans out there, might know how severe it is?

Warner? Hmmm. I still think you should keep McNabb. I think he could finish as a top-5 QB this year.

Maybe you could try to sell high on Warner while you can. You know he's one good hit away from missing a couple weeks.

And Colston ought to be back in a few weeks, right? He should be rounding into form during the last half of the season.

[steve]

It's Warner.

I lost Colston at WR as well. 

I'd be taking a chance on Grant becoming healthy, any Greenbay fans out there, might know how severe it is?

Warner? Hmmm. I still think you should keep McNabb. I think he could finish as a top-5 QB this year.

Maybe you could try to sell high on Warner while you can. You know he's one good hit away from missing a couple weeks.

And Colston ought to be back in a few weeks, right? He should be rounding into form during the last half of the season.

True.  You guys are swaying me away from this trade.  This is tough. 

[steve]

I just got another trade offer from the guy that wants McNabb...

McNabb and Turner

for

Gore and Hienze Ward

[Lucky17]

I just got another trade offer from the guy that wants McNabb...

McNabb and Turner

for

Gore and Hienze Ward

I had Gore last year, and he left such a bad taste in my mouth that I swore I'd never draft or trade for him again. He ought to do better this year, now that SF actually has someone at QB that can keep defenses from playing the run every down, but I still don't do this trade.

Obviously, the guy wants McNabb. I'd see if he'd be willing to take Warner instead. Looks like he's willing to part with Ward.

Which do you need more, a WR or a RB?

[steve]

I just got another trade offer from the guy that wants McNabb...

McNabb and Turner

for

Gore and Hienze Ward

I had Gore last year, and he left such a bad taste in my mouth that I swore I'd never draft or trade for him again. He ought to do better this year, now that SF actually has someone at QB that can keep defenses from playing the run every down, but I still don't do this trade.

Obviously, the guy wants McNabb. I'd see if he'd be willing to take Warner instead. Looks like he's willing to part with Ward.

Which do you need more, a WR or a RB?

[steve]

Colston, Cotchery, Harrison, Desaun (I'll celebrate when I want to celebrate) Jackson, Crayton, Bryant Johnson

LT, Sproles, Turner, M Bush

[Lucky17]

Colston, Cotchery, Harrison, Desaun (I'll celebrate when I want to celebrate) Jackson, Crayton, Bryant Johnson

LT, Sproles, Turner, M Bush

Might be a tough sell, but I try to entice the other guy with Warner, plus one of your receivers, for either Ward or a RB (he's already offered you Grant and Gore).

[Larrybird17]

I made a trade with my buddy last night in our fantasy football league. I traded away Marvin Harrison and Rashard Mendenhall for Lee Evans and Ahman Green. I know it's not the biggest deal but in a 16 team league every little bit counts. Do you guys think I got the better of this deal or did I get hosed? Mind you a big reason I am so nervous about this trade has to do with the fact that two years ago I traded Maurice Jones Drew to the same guy for JP Losman straight up... neddless to say history hasn't been on my side in our deals.

[JSD]

This thread should be merged with Fantasy Football feedback...


"Please help me" is a little dramatic for a fantasy football question isn't it?