Thanks for passing that along -- I very much like when these discussions involve actual evidence. I totally believe you on the rotations -- I side with John Hollinger of ESPN in believing the other upsides to Powe outweigh his rotation troubles.
Just to confirm what I was saying, here is Doc talking about Powe's trouble with the rotations, and how good Perk, Garnett, PJ, and even Baby are at rotating compared to Powe (start listening at about the 12 minute mark).
http://audio.weei.com/m/19948987/doc_rivers.htm
I agree with this in general...except that for some reason, his "other upsides" have been lacking. In the majority of the games he has not been nearly as effective on the offensive side of the ball, or rebounding as he was in the regular season.
There are lots of theories for why, but I personally just think it is because interior defense steps up about 5 notches in the playoffs, so it makes it so much tougher to get anything done in there...especially when you are undersized. He did much of his damage in the regular season, when the defenses weren't rotating to him off of plays by perimeter players. So far in the playoffs, those rotations have been there.
So if he is not giving you a lot more offensively, than the defense stands out that much more.
I also would argue that because every time up the court is so much more important, that changes the philosophy. Defense is MUCH more important than offense in the playoffs.
<<<I agree with this in general...except that for some reason, his "other upsides" have been lacking. In the majority of the games he has not been nearly as effective on the offensive side of the ball, or rebounding as he was in the regular season.>>>
Maybe his "other upsides" are lacking because Powe has played 6,4,0,7,8,3,0, and one minute in the past 8 games. Now I know Rivers knows more about the game of basketball and his players than I do, but I don't think you can say for a fact Powe's "other upsides" are lacking because he's been playing poorly.
How can anybody judge whether Powe can rebound, take charges or score in exactly 3.62 minutes a game since Powe has been relegated to the doghouse? Can you, Chris? Rivers didn't even start playing Powe until approximately the 38th game of the year which probably has a direct correlation to Garnett's injury. I'm of the opinion Rivers doesn't really know what Powe can do but perhaps only what he perceives Powe can't do.... which is being quicker and or smarter on his rotations. I still question this inability of Powe's because for somebody who can't make the rotations as fast as all on this board want Powe to make them, Powe comes up with a lot of charges....meaning he has to be in the right defensive position in the first place.
<<<There are lots of theories for why, but I personally just think it is because interior defense steps up about 5 notches in the playoffs, so it makes it so much tougher to get anything done in there...especially when you are undersized. He did much of his damage in the regular season, when the defenses weren't rotating to him off of plays by perimeter players. So far in the playoffs, those rotations have been there.>>>
Again, if you take the playoff games where Powe has played 10 minutes or more, Powe has average 7.2 pts and 4.1 rebs per game on an average of 19 minutes per game (9 games). In five of those games Powe went for 10, 10, 9, 12, and 11 points. Yeah, maybe Powe can't put these numbers up against the Pistons, but it's not because he's playing poorly but because he's not playing enough. Even in the playoffs, when given a chance, Powe has done pretty well.
<<<So if he is not giving you a lot more offensively, than the defense stands out that much more.>>>
As far as I can tell, Powe has been given absolutely no opportunity to do anything from an offensive standpoint in the last 8 games. Really an unfair statement about Powe, Chris. Hell, he hasn't even been given much of a chance to f**k up on the defensive end either.
<<<I also would argue that because every time up the court is so much more important, that changes the philosophy. Defense is MUCH more important than offense in the playoffs.>>>
Whatever defensive lapses Powe has during a game he offsets them with a charge, an offensive board or getting fouls on opposing players. Since Davis is taking most of Powe's playing time over the past 8 games, I would say blocked shots are like turnovers and turnovers are just as bad as missing an assignment on a defensive rotation. And it seemed like the Celtics had a bit of "Poweitis" on the defensive end last night. I think you're going to get your wish by next year....Powe will probably be gone.