Brown vs White: On/Off and Assessing a Player's Value?

[Celtics4ever]

Nique was a way more dominant scorer than Jaylen.  Brown is better than McDaniel.

I think Brown is close to Jimmy Butler.  Look at their stats.

                 Brown                       Butler
Position   Guard / Forward   Guard / Forward
Scoring      ~23-26 PPG            ~21-23 PPG
Rebounding   ~5.5 RPG           ~5.5 RPG
Shooting      ~49% FG          ~49% FG

Jimmy could sometimes take over games though more so than Brown.

[Moranis]

Nique was a way more dominant scorer than Jaylen.  Brown is better than McDaniel.

I think Brown is close to Jimmy Butler.  Look at their stats.

                 Brown                       Butler
Position   Guard / Forward   Guard / Forward
Scoring      ~23-26 PPG            ~21-23 PPG
Rebounding   ~5.5 RPG           ~5.5 RPG
Shooting      ~49% FG          ~49% FG

Jimmy could sometimes take over games though more so than Brown.

However, Butler's teams were always much worse when he wasn't in the game.  He has generally had an elite or borderline elite on/off differential.  He improves every team he is on in large part because of the stats you don't show i.e. 4.4 apg to just 1.6 tpg. A 2.75 assist to turnover ratio is fantastic as is his very low turnover rate.  Butler generates as many steals i.e. 1.6 as he commits turnovers.  He also doesnt commit fouls at just 1.4 fouls per game.  Butler plays winning basketball on both ends of the floor. He always has.  Brown does not.  Brown's impact to winning is basically non-existent because he doesn't play winning basketball. He is a very good player, his skill set just isn't conducive to winning.  That doesn't mean you can't win with him as Boston has obviously done that, but plenty of teams have won with non-winning players on their roster even in starting roles.  We saw this year what a Jaylen Brown led team looks like i.e. lots of stats and regular season wins, but limited post season success. 

[Vermont Green]

Jaylen Brown holds a career winning record of 523?293, which includes a 440?234 regular-season record and an 83?59 playoff record. Combined, this gives the Boston Celtics star an overall career winning percentage of approximately \(64.1\%\)

Jimmy Butler holds a career regular-season record of 546-361 (.602 winning percentage), and a postseason record of 63-67 (.485 winning percentage).

I think Jimmy Butler has been a more impactful player overall than Jaylen Brown, but it is a pretty good comp.  Both have one 2nd team all NBA and multiple 3rd team.  And Jaylen Brown has won more than Butler, regular season and playoffs.  Winning or not rarely comes down to one player, but it is a fact that Brown's teams have won more than Butler's teams.

[Donoghus]

Nique was a way more dominant scorer than Jaylen.  Brown is better than McDaniel.

I think Brown is close to Jimmy Butler.  Look at their stats.

                 Brown                       Butler
Position   Guard / Forward   Guard / Forward
Scoring      ~23-26 PPG            ~21-23 PPG
Rebounding   ~5.5 RPG           ~5.5 RPG
Shooting      ~49% FG          ~49% FG

Jimmy could sometimes take over games though more so than Brown.

However, Butler's teams were always much worse when he wasn't in the game.  He has generally had an elite or borderline elite on/off differential.  He improves every team he is on in large part because of the stats you don't show i.e. 4.4 apg to just 1.6 tpg. A 2.75 assist to turnover ratio is fantastic as is his very low turnover rate.  Butler generates as many steals i.e. 1.6 as he commits turnovers.  He also doesnt commit fouls at just 1.4 fouls per game.  Butler plays winning basketball on both ends of the floor. He always has.  Brown does not. Brown's impact to winning is basically non-existent because he doesn't play winning basketball. He is a very good player, his skill set just isn't conducive to winning. That doesn't mean you can't win with him as Boston has obviously done that, but plenty of teams have won with non-winning players on their roster even in starting roles.  We saw this year what a Jaylen Brown led team looks like i.e. lots of stats and regular season wins, but limited post season success.

This nonsense again?

[DefenseWinsChamps]

Nique was a way more dominant scorer than Jaylen.  Brown is better than McDaniel.

I think Brown is close to Jimmy Butler.  Look at their stats.

                 Brown                       Butler
Position   Guard / Forward   Guard / Forward
Scoring      ~23-26 PPG            ~21-23 PPG
Rebounding   ~5.5 RPG           ~5.5 RPG
Shooting      ~49% FG          ~49% FG

Jimmy could sometimes take over games though more so than Brown.

However, Butler's teams were always much worse when he wasn't in the game.  He has generally had an elite or borderline elite on/off differential.  He improves every team he is on in large part because of the stats you don't show i.e. 4.4 apg to just 1.6 tpg. A 2.75 assist to turnover ratio is fantastic as is his very low turnover rate.  Butler generates as many steals i.e. 1.6 as he commits turnovers.  He also doesnt commit fouls at just 1.4 fouls per game.  Butler plays winning basketball on both ends of the floor. He always has.  Brown does not.  Brown's impact to winning is basically non-existent because he doesn't play winning basketball. He is a very good player, his skill set just isn't conducive to winning.  That doesn't mean you can't win with him as Boston has obviously done that, but plenty of teams have won with non-winning players on their roster even in starting roles.  We saw this year what a Jaylen Brown led team looks like i.e. lots of stats and regular season wins, but limited post season success.

That's way too broad of a statement. Brown doesn't play winning basketball? He's won a championship and earned a finals MVP. He's in an elite group of winning players already.

I think Butler in his prime probably had a greater overall impact on his team than Brown did this last year, but claiming that Brown doesn't play winning basketball is not only untrue, it undercuts your points here.

An over-reliance on advanced stats is a market inequality right now in the NBA. Atkinson's quote before game 4 about how they should be up 2-1 in the series according to the stats shows this tone deafness in the advanced stats community. I think your insistence that the Cavs would tie the series in their two games at home after the eye test showed multiple problems with that theory like: 1) Harden collapses in big games, 2) Mobley clearly struggles with physicality, 3) Mitchell did not look like himself 4) the Knicks stole the Cavs soul in game 1.

I think advanced stats are helpful, especially with players like Butler who has good-not-great counting stats, because they reveal a true superstar career impact. They show a path forward. They help you focus on the winning processes, but the game is played on the court.

[Moranis]

Nique was a way more dominant scorer than Jaylen.  Brown is better than McDaniel.

I think Brown is close to Jimmy Butler.  Look at their stats.

                 Brown                       Butler
Position   Guard / Forward   Guard / Forward
Scoring      ~23-26 PPG            ~21-23 PPG
Rebounding   ~5.5 RPG           ~5.5 RPG
Shooting      ~49% FG          ~49% FG

Jimmy could sometimes take over games though more so than Brown.

However, Butler's teams were always much worse when he wasn't in the game.  He has generally had an elite or borderline elite on/off differential.  He improves every team he is on in large part because of the stats you don't show i.e. 4.4 apg to just 1.6 tpg. A 2.75 assist to turnover ratio is fantastic as is his very low turnover rate.  Butler generates as many steals i.e. 1.6 as he commits turnovers.  He also doesnt commit fouls at just 1.4 fouls per game.  Butler plays winning basketball on both ends of the floor. He always has.  Brown does not. Brown's impact to winning is basically non-existent because he doesn't play winning basketball. He is a very good player, his skill set just isn't conducive to winning. That doesn't mean you can't win with him as Boston has obviously done that, but plenty of teams have won with non-winning players on their roster even in starting roles.  We saw this year what a Jaylen Brown led team looks like i.e. lots of stats and regular season wins, but limited post season success.

This nonsense again?

This season more than any other has proven that to be true.