Have to think OKC is trying to move away from the legal drama surrounding Giddey and Bulls looking to add young potential they could control.
I assume there's a pick involved going to OKC? Or was it a one to one swap?
Alex Caruso is a good player for OKC. I think Giddey can be a really good play when that shot develops...
Nothing about Caruso being good for them or not, I just don't see how you trade a 21yo with potential, who you picked at #6, who'll be a RFA for a 30yo Alex Caruso straight up who also has only 1 year on his contract.
It's not like Giddey has been a flop, he's been overall solid for them. So something else should be driving this trade, so I imagine a pick at least to be involved otherwise... and maybe even then.
Giddey just isn't really god at the things you need to be good at to win.
He can dribble and pass, but he can't shoot or finish at the rim which severely limits is offensive contributions. He doesn't really put any pressure on a defense, doesn't generate any advantages.
On defense he's not awful, but he plays much smaller than his size.
Its just hard to say what exactly he does to help to a team actually win.
I wouldn't write-off a 21yo who is fairly efficient with the ball. Again, you don't trade that type of player for a 1yr rental of 30yo Caruso. Someone, despite your assertions, was a contributor in helping the 2nd youngest team in the NBA to achieve the 2nd best record in the league. That's nothing to sniff at, to say nothing that having a player like that as a RFA is valuable.
You're not wrong on a lot of what you're saying here, as a lot of that was shown in the Dallas series, but it lacks perspective of youth and contract situation. If he were a non-contributor who's playing bad basketball it would be one thing, but he's been solid player on an incredibly young team who went to the 2nd round of the playoffs and he had a part in that. Not a huge part, but good throughout most of year.
So this trade screams that it's more of off the court reasons, than basketball or front office cap related reasons.