Butler with a ferocious 13 points tonight
If Miami loses in 4 or 5 will there be excuses made for Butler or will he actually get criticized like many other stars would?
Baffles me how much criticism he escapes from the media
It is pretty amazing. Jimmy Butler just led his team to his 2nd finals appearance. How man guys have done that?
This is Karl Malone & John Stockton territory.
True. I like Butler myself. I just find it odd he never seems to get any criticism from the media at all. Not like KD, Tatum, Doncic, AD, etc if they have even one bad game. If Boston lost today and JT had 13 you know the media would rip Tatum about it
Still a ways to go, but if Miami’s role players revert to their usual selves then Butler better be prepared to go off the next 4-5 games or it’s over quick
I was thinking of Jason Kidd - another guy who led his team to two NBA Finals. Another guy who was a dodgy jump-shooter like Jimmy Butler is. Another guy who largely escaped criticism when he had a bad night.
I wonder if it is partly about the jump-shooting. People just don't respect Jimmy as a perimeter scorer. Great slasher. Great at getting to the FT line. Good midrange shot. Dodgy outside shot. Just not going to be as consistent as other top scorers. More up and down. Like J Kidd with his dodgy shot.
And then partly respect for his non-scoring game. Even if Jimmy doesn't shoot well, if he doesn't score well, Jimmy will still play All-League level defense, give you strong rebounding, give you good ball-handling and playmaking. Heck, Jimmy is basically Miami's PG. He is their main playmaker. He is dominant player outside of scoring so even when he doesn't score he still helps the team. Similar to J Kidd.
Also, there is never a lack of effort. A lack of focus. Lack of intensity. Guys never question Jimmy on that. Guys never questioned J Kidd on that. They do question other guys. Say Carmelo Anthony. Does he work hard enough on defense? Does he pass the ball enough? Does he settle for low percentage shots too often? How badly does he want to win? Will he dive for that loose ball? Jimmy will. J Kidd will.
Also, not playing in NY, BOS or LA helps. Miami an easier going market to play in. Newer fan base. Easy going crowds at their arena.