Players I want to see us keep:
Defense: Dugger, Marcus Jones, Judon, Barmore (flashed last year and bits this year, but has battled injuries) Uche (finally has popped off.) Obviously you keep the rookies because they are so cost controlled.
On Offense: Onwenu (has quietly been very good now that he is back to his natural position. He and Andrews are our only good lineman right now.) Thornton,and Stevenson.
For Mac, I honestly can't tell if the lack of any type of offensive system has destroyed him. He is making bad reads, but so much of our dysfunction comes from the top. We won't be in a position to snag elite talent at the QB, so we have to roll forward with him for now.
Edit: And honestly, if somebody gave me a legit offer for Judon, I would jump at it. I think we need to build for the future, and he probably only has an elite year or maybe two left.