I think Perkins going down in game 6 of the 2010 finals cost us a banner.
But the following year, we were playing some of our "very best" basketball before Perkins came back alter in the season.
Shaq playing 10-15 minutes a night was more than enough. Unfortunately Shaq got injured - a guy who had never suffered a "serious" injury his entire carer.
I like Jeff Green - I think he's far more valuable than Kendrick Perkins - then and now. Having a hobbled Perkins still would have been no guarantee that we win the title. To be honest I thought it was more of a mistake to trade Semih Erden "as well as" Perkins.
That team just needed a big, active, physical body in the middle for 15-20 minutes a night. The talent and the winning still lay heavily with KG, Pierce, Ray and Rondo.
For me the fact that we didn't replace the tough guys we lost was more important than the fact that we lost them.
We could have replaced:
Posey with Matt Barnes
Powe with Reggie Evans
Perkins with Aaron Gray
Etc...
When you have a core of KG, Pierce, Ray and Rondo, guys like Perkins, Posey & TAllen, the tough guy, glue guy types are interchangeable.
But you actually "do have to replace them" if you're going to let them go...
TAllen with another tough defender