There's pretty much no denying he was our second best player this past season.
A few things I noted in this thread:
1. He's the best defender on the team.
- while that is true, that's severely under rating him. He's one of the best defenders in the entire NBA, no doubt about that.
2. He's too short to defend.
- even though he's not a tall SG, he plays so tight and gets his hands right in their sight line and bothers more shots than players much taller than him.
3. Need to spend money on stud scorers.
- Avery was a 17ppg scorer on a pretty efficient clip (esp from deep). He can score AND all-world defense.
4. He's likely to approach $25-30M a season.
- that's for max players. He's a very good player, and IMO a borderline all-star. But he will get somewhere in the $17-20M salary. Even if he does get showered with $25+M per offers, don't you think that means many GM's think he's worth it?
All in all, I would rather keep him over Smart if both are going to get paid after the upcoming season. I like his shooting and defense more than Smart's play making. If you put Rozier and Tatum together with the second unit, they should score enough, especially with one starter in there (assuming we land two more stars).