Author Topic: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs  (Read 23164 times)

0 Members and 0 Guests are viewing this topic.

Re: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs
« Reply #60 on: May 07, 2017, 07:48:30 PM »

Online Neurotic Guy

  • Tommy Heinsohn
  • *************************
  • Posts: 25541
  • Tommy Points: 2720
Ive never seen anything quite like Shaq (a mammoth with body control), like Magic (6'9" with elite pg skills and elite vision), like Bird (deceptive athleticism, court vision, coordination and a stroke sent from the gods), like Michael (athletic marvel with size, all-around skills and competetive obsession) or like Lebron (6'8" muscle-bound athletic freak of nature, unstoppable freight train with body control).   

LBJ is in the pantheon, no doubt in my mind.

Re: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs
« Reply #61 on: May 07, 2017, 10:19:35 PM »

Offline Moranis

  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 34527
  • Tommy Points: 1597
Quote
The reality is James gets blamed for things that aren't his fault and that all of the greats have which just get ignored when discrediting James.  If anything James should be praised for growing up in the internet era and actually living up to the immense hype placed on him by others.  Especially off the court where it is no contest on who the better person is (Jordan is widely known as one of the biggest jerks in sports history, very few former teammates even talk to him and his HOF speech was one of the most uncomfortable speeches ever and let's not talk about the gambling, cheating, etc. that is easy to find by google).

I do think he deserves some of the credit for the media age.   I don't agree with the blamed for things that aren't his fault.   If you're the greatest player of your age you have to man up and take the mantle and all that comes with it.  You should take the blame.

I also think there is some circumstantial evidence that the KING may have used PEDs.  LeBron used the Biogenesis Clinic.

Quote
Coincidentally enough, James’s agent and best friend’s name is Rich Paul. Now if it’s the same Mr. Paul or not, that wasn’t confirmed. However, Jessica said some of her coworkers were 100% sure that Lebron James was a client of the instute and was the “LJ.”

https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/mlb/2015/02/17/former-owner-of-mlb-steroid-clinic-sentenced-to-4-years/23548467/

https://www.si.com/si-wire/2013/07/25/biogenesis-whistle-blower-nba-players

http://dystnow.com/2013/03/04/lebron-james-jameer-nelson-linked-to-miami-steroid-clinic/

http://uproxx.com/dimemag/did-bill-simmons-hint-that-lebron-james-took-a-steroid-vacation/2/

http://ftw.usatoday.com/2016/12/nba-ped-drug-testing-george-karl-book

It could be nothing but LBJ could be the Sammy Sosa of the NBA, who know....No one ever said that rumor of that of Magic, Michael or Larry.

These guys who are great players often have big egos, they believe in themselves and it is part of what makes them great players.   It does not make them nice human beings.  I am solely measuring them as players, though.  All the he is jerk or not a nice guy is a smoke screen when we are talking about GOAT, though.   I would argue the case of Pete Rose as an example, no one has hit the hit king's total, but the guy is a horrible human being, but that had zero effect on his ability to play and maybe even enhanced it.

Interesting. I don't really have strong feelings one way or the other, but I do think people that think half the league isn't pushing the envelope on what is legal arepretty naive. The biggest thing with steroids or performance enhancers isn't really adding strength, though it does, it also largely helps in recovery and injury prevention/recovery. The flip side of it is people could point at our own horford and his odd pectoral injuries and make the same accusation.
and to think the players in the 90's weren't using steroids is just naive.  Look at baseball, football, etc.
the technology for steroids has really changed since the 90s. As far as I have ever read HGH was not very common at all during the 90s if it existed at all. The steroids also had very harsh and real side effects. Obviously they were around using but we really are talking about two different things. If you are trying to argue that you think Jordan may have been a steroid user you are actually the first person I have ever heard float that idea. Which says a couple of things including that you got to tone your Lebron fandom
the thing is there are no actual links that James was a client of biogensis or that even if he was that he was taking banned substances. Lots of people took perfectly legal supplements from biogenesis.

And for the record there are plenty of stories on the net linking Jordan to steroids beginning around the time he met Tim Grover in the summer of 1989 at which time MJ bulked up significantly at the age of 27. If you believe he started using roids at that time it would also explain why he began distancing himself from teammates and started being far more prickly and even getting into fights i.e. roid rage and covering tracks (he also went bald). Remember this was before the internet and during a time when sports reporters didn't report on a lot of the off court stuff because they needed to keep relationships.

It also might explain why all of a sudden MJ retired out of the blue, some feel he was suspended for gambling but it easily could have been steroids and the league wanted to cover it up so let him "retire".  I don't have any idea if he was forced to retire or just needed a break but you could connect the dots if you felt he was using roids

At the end of the day I ave no idea if MJ was using just like I have no idea if James ever did, but neither was caught (or at least known to be caught) so I'd give both the benefit of the doubt.
« Last Edit: May 07, 2017, 11:34:22 PM by Moranis »
2023 Historical Draft - Brooklyn Nets - 9th pick

Bigs - Pau, Amar'e, Issel, McGinnis, Roundfield
Wings - Dantley, Bowen, J. Jackson
Guards - Cheeks, Petrovic, Buse, Rip

Re: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs
« Reply #62 on: May 08, 2017, 12:18:31 AM »

Offline celticsclay

  • JoJo White
  • ****************
  • Posts: 16176
  • Tommy Points: 1407
Quote
The reality is James gets blamed for things that aren't his fault and that all of the greats have which just get ignored when discrediting James.  If anything James should be praised for growing up in the internet era and actually living up to the immense hype placed on him by others.  Especially off the court where it is no contest on who the better person is (Jordan is widely known as one of the biggest jerks in sports history, very few former teammates even talk to him and his HOF speech was one of the most uncomfortable speeches ever and let's not talk about the gambling, cheating, etc. that is easy to find by google).

I do think he deserves some of the credit for the media age.   I don't agree with the blamed for things that aren't his fault.   If you're the greatest player of your age you have to man up and take the mantle and all that comes with it.  You should take the blame.

I also think there is some circumstantial evidence that the KING may have used PEDs.  LeBron used the Biogenesis Clinic.

Quote
Coincidentally enough, James’s agent and best friend’s name is Rich Paul. Now if it’s the same Mr. Paul or not, that wasn’t confirmed. However, Jessica said some of her coworkers were 100% sure that Lebron James was a client of the instute and was the “LJ.”

https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/mlb/2015/02/17/former-owner-of-mlb-steroid-clinic-sentenced-to-4-years/23548467/

https://www.si.com/si-wire/2013/07/25/biogenesis-whistle-blower-nba-players

http://dystnow.com/2013/03/04/lebron-james-jameer-nelson-linked-to-miami-steroid-clinic/

http://uproxx.com/dimemag/did-bill-simmons-hint-that-lebron-james-took-a-steroid-vacation/2/

http://ftw.usatoday.com/2016/12/nba-ped-drug-testing-george-karl-book

It could be nothing but LBJ could be the Sammy Sosa of the NBA, who know....No one ever said that rumor of that of Magic, Michael or Larry.

These guys who are great players often have big egos, they believe in themselves and it is part of what makes them great players.   It does not make them nice human beings.  I am solely measuring them as players, though.  All the he is jerk or not a nice guy is a smoke screen when we are talking about GOAT, though.   I would argue the case of Pete Rose as an example, no one has hit the hit king's total, but the guy is a horrible human being, but that had zero effect on his ability to play and maybe even enhanced it.

Interesting. I don't really have strong feelings one way or the other, but I do think people that think half the league isn't pushing the envelope on what is legal arepretty naive. The biggest thing with steroids or performance enhancers isn't really adding strength, though it does, it also largely helps in recovery and injury prevention/recovery. The flip side of it is people could point at our own horford and his odd pectoral injuries and make the same accusation.
and to think the players in the 90's weren't using steroids is just naive.  Look at baseball, football, etc.
the technology for steroids has really changed since the 90s. As far as I have ever read HGH was not very common at all during the 90s if it existed at all. The steroids also had very harsh and real side effects. Obviously they were around using but we really are talking about two different things. If you are trying to argue that you think Jordan may have been a steroid user you are actually the first person I have ever heard float that idea. Which says a couple of things including that you got to tone your Lebron fandom
the thing is there are no actual links that James was a client of biogensis or that even if he was that he was taking banned substances. Lots of people took perfectly legal supplements from biogenesis.

And for the record there are plenty of stories on the net linking Jordan to steroids beginning around the time he met Tim Grover in the summer of 1989 at which time MJ bulked up significantly at the age of 27. If you believe he started using roids at that time it would also explain why he began distancing himself from teammates and started being far more prickly and even getting into fights i.e. roid rage and covering tracks (he also went bald). Remember this was before the internet and during a time when sports reporters didn't report on a lot of the off court stuff because they needed to keep relationships.

It also might explain why all of a sudden MJ retired out of the blue, some feel he was suspended for gambling but it easily could have been steroids and the league wanted to cover it up so let him "retire".  I don't have any idea if he was forced to retire or just needed a break but you could connect the dots if you felt he was using roids

At the end of the day I ave no idea if MJ was using just like I have no idea if James ever did, but neither was caught (or at least known to be caught) so I'd give both the benefit of the doubt.

Wow even for you. Lol

side note, this is so crazy I have to see if anyone else has ever heard this and it deserves it's own thread.
« Last Edit: May 08, 2017, 02:57:22 AM by celticsclay »

Re: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs
« Reply #63 on: May 08, 2017, 08:17:18 AM »

Offline Big333223

  • NCE
  • Tiny Archibald
  • *******
  • Posts: 7833
  • Tommy Points: 770
I will say this: in my opinion Scottie Pippen is a better teammate than Lebron's ever had, and Pippen/Rodman trumps anything Lebron has had as well.
This is something worth digging into, for me. I've got Wade ahead of Pippen, but Pippen was a much better fit alongside Jordan than Wade was alongside Lebron. So that has to factor into this, too. Not just who had better teammates but who had the better "team". In other words whose team was better constructed to maximize its own talents and the talents of its star? I think Jordan wound up being very fortunate in that regard, especially when you take coaching into account.
1957, 1959, 1960, 1961, 1962, 1963, 1964, 1965, 1966, 1968, 1969, 1974, 1976, 1981, 1984, 1986, 2008, 2024

Re: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs
« Reply #64 on: May 08, 2017, 08:59:48 AM »

Offline Moranis

  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 34527
  • Tommy Points: 1597
I will say this: in my opinion Scottie Pippen is a better teammate than Lebron's ever had, and Pippen/Rodman trumps anything Lebron has had as well.
This is something worth digging into, for me. I've got Wade ahead of Pippen, but Pippen was a much better fit alongside Jordan than Wade was alongside Lebron. So that has to factor into this, too. Not just who had better teammates but who had the better "team". In other words whose team was better constructed to maximize its own talents and the talents of its star? I think Jordan wound up being very fortunate in that regard, especially when you take coaching into account.
Wade was definitely a better top end scorer but that is all he was better at than Pippen who was a significantly better defender and rebounder.  Wade though really only had 1 in prime season with James before the injuries started mounting up and took away much of what made Wade great.
2023 Historical Draft - Brooklyn Nets - 9th pick

Bigs - Pau, Amar'e, Issel, McGinnis, Roundfield
Wings - Dantley, Bowen, J. Jackson
Guards - Cheeks, Petrovic, Buse, Rip

Re: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs
« Reply #65 on: May 08, 2017, 09:22:48 AM »

Offline Big333223

  • NCE
  • Tiny Archibald
  • *******
  • Posts: 7833
  • Tommy Points: 770
I will say this: in my opinion Scottie Pippen is a better teammate than Lebron's ever had, and Pippen/Rodman trumps anything Lebron has had as well.
This is something worth digging into, for me. I've got Wade ahead of Pippen, but Pippen was a much better fit alongside Jordan than Wade was alongside Lebron. So that has to factor into this, too. Not just who had better teammates but who had the better "team". In other words whose team was better constructed to maximize its own talents and the talents of its star? I think Jordan wound up being very fortunate in that regard, especially when you take coaching into account.
Wade was definitely a better top end scorer but that is all he was better at than Pippen who was a significantly better defender and rebounder.  Wade though really only had 1 in prime season with James before the injuries started mounting up and took away much of what made Wade great.
I agree Pippen was the more versatile player but Wade was pretty versatile in his own right and I think his best was better than Pippen's best. If I'm starting a team, I'm definitely picking Wade before Pippen. On the other hand, if I already have Jordan or Lebron (or Bird or Magic) I'm picking Pippen before I pick Wade.
1957, 1959, 1960, 1961, 1962, 1963, 1964, 1965, 1966, 1968, 1969, 1974, 1976, 1981, 1984, 1986, 2008, 2024

Re: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs
« Reply #66 on: May 08, 2017, 10:27:43 AM »

Offline Moranis

  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 34527
  • Tommy Points: 1597
I will say this: in my opinion Scottie Pippen is a better teammate than Lebron's ever had, and Pippen/Rodman trumps anything Lebron has had as well.
This is something worth digging into, for me. I've got Wade ahead of Pippen, but Pippen was a much better fit alongside Jordan than Wade was alongside Lebron. So that has to factor into this, too. Not just who had better teammates but who had the better "team". In other words whose team was better constructed to maximize its own talents and the talents of its star? I think Jordan wound up being very fortunate in that regard, especially when you take coaching into account.
Wade was definitely a better top end scorer but that is all he was better at than Pippen who was a significantly better defender and rebounder.  Wade though really only had 1 in prime season with James before the injuries started mounting up and took away much of what made Wade great.
I agree Pippen was the more versatile player but Wade was pretty versatile in his own right and I think his best was better than Pippen's best. If I'm starting a team, I'm definitely picking Wade before Pippen. On the other hand, if I already have Jordan or Lebron (or Bird or Magic) I'm picking Pippen before I pick Wade.
fair point but James didn't have prime Wade in Miami. Wade started his decline and got worse every year with James, that absolutely has to be factored in.  Especially considering all of the games Wade missed due to injury.
 Jordan played with Pippen during Pippen's entire prime (well except the year MJ took off).
2023 Historical Draft - Brooklyn Nets - 9th pick

Bigs - Pau, Amar'e, Issel, McGinnis, Roundfield
Wings - Dantley, Bowen, J. Jackson
Guards - Cheeks, Petrovic, Buse, Rip

Re: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs
« Reply #67 on: May 08, 2017, 11:31:12 AM »

Offline Big333223

  • NCE
  • Tiny Archibald
  • *******
  • Posts: 7833
  • Tommy Points: 770
I will say this: in my opinion Scottie Pippen is a better teammate than Lebron's ever had, and Pippen/Rodman trumps anything Lebron has had as well.
This is something worth digging into, for me. I've got Wade ahead of Pippen, but Pippen was a much better fit alongside Jordan than Wade was alongside Lebron. So that has to factor into this, too. Not just who had better teammates but who had the better "team". In other words whose team was better constructed to maximize its own talents and the talents of its star? I think Jordan wound up being very fortunate in that regard, especially when you take coaching into account.
Wade was definitely a better top end scorer but that is all he was better at than Pippen who was a significantly better defender and rebounder.  Wade though really only had 1 in prime season with James before the injuries started mounting up and took away much of what made Wade great.
I agree Pippen was the more versatile player but Wade was pretty versatile in his own right and I think his best was better than Pippen's best. If I'm starting a team, I'm definitely picking Wade before Pippen. On the other hand, if I already have Jordan or Lebron (or Bird or Magic) I'm picking Pippen before I pick Wade.
fair point but James didn't have prime Wade in Miami. Wade started his decline and got worse every year with James, that absolutely has to be factored in.  Especially considering all of the games Wade missed due to injury.
 Jordan played with Pippen during Pippen's entire prime (well except the year MJ took off).
I'd quibble about just when Wade started to decline (I think he was basically still in his prime those first 3 seasons, the statistical decline had to do with a role change) but I generally agree that Lebron didn't get Wade's best the whole 4 seasons.
1957, 1959, 1960, 1961, 1962, 1963, 1964, 1965, 1966, 1968, 1969, 1974, 1976, 1981, 1984, 1986, 2008, 2024

Re: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs
« Reply #68 on: May 08, 2017, 12:38:29 PM »

Offline celticsclay

  • JoJo White
  • ****************
  • Posts: 16176
  • Tommy Points: 1407
Something that has not been mentioned in this thread, it really can not be argued that the East is not incredibly flawed weak right now. Perhaps the weakest it has ever been. While I hated seeing it, it wasn't completely unjustified for people to call us the weakest number 1 seed ever. Of the top teams in the east we don't really have a superstar. Neither does Toronto. Neither does Atlanta. Perhaps Wall is the closest to a superstar in his prime in the conference on a top tier team outside of Cleveland.

Who was Lebron beating to get to the finals?

Jordan's first 3peat really had some formidable teams. One of them was, ironically, the Cavs. The Cavs had a 4 time all-star in Mark Price, Brad Daugherty a 5x all star and Larry Nance a 3x all star. What team in the east this year is closest to that?

Other notable teams in the east included the 60 win Knicks team featuring superstar and future hall of famer Ewing in his prime with both Starks and Oakley making the all star the following year.

Even at team like the Pistons had a still effective Dumars and Thomas in the all star game and Dennis Rodman pulling down an astonishing 18 rebounds a game. 

Unfortunately now when you think about the best players in the game Harden, Westbrook, Curry, Thompson, Durant, Lillard, Davis, Leonard are all in the west. How many east players even make the all-NBA teams 5 out of 15? It really is unfortunate because I would love to see the East be more competitive and the playoffs are honestly pretty boring at the moment.

Re: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs
« Reply #69 on: May 08, 2017, 12:58:36 PM »

Offline kraidstar

  • Paul Silas
  • ******
  • Posts: 6077
  • Tommy Points: 2569
Something that has not been mentioned in this thread, it really can not be argued that the East is not incredibly flawed weak right now. Perhaps the weakest it has ever been. While I hated seeing it, it wasn't completely unjustified for people to call us the weakest number 1 seed ever. Of the top teams in the east we don't really have a superstar. Neither does Toronto. Neither does Atlanta. Perhaps Wall is the closest to a superstar in his prime in the conference on a top tier team outside of Cleveland.

Who was Lebron beating to get to the finals?

Jordan's first 3peat really had some formidable teams. One of them was, ironically, the Cavs. The Cavs had a 4 time all-star in Mark Price, Brad Daugherty a 5x all star and Larry Nance a 3x all star. What team in the east this year is closest to that?

Other notable teams in the east included the 60 win Knicks team featuring superstar and future hall of famer Ewing in his prime with both Starks and Oakley making the all star the following year.

Even at team like the Pistons had a still effective Dumars and Thomas in the all star game and Dennis Rodman pulling down an astonishing 18 rebounds a game. 

Unfortunately now when you think about the best players in the game Harden, Westbrook, Curry, Thompson, Durant, Lillard, Davis, Leonard are all in the west. How many east players even make the all-NBA teams 5 out of 15? It really is unfortunate because I would love to see the East be more competitive and the playoffs are honestly pretty boring at the moment.
The Bulls never won until the C's and Pistons declined.

Then the expansion era started, with half a dozen new teams watering down the talent pool. There were some great players in the 90's but the teams themselves had questionable depth.

The 1993 Houston Rockets won a championship with
Hakeem
Otis Thorpe
Vernon Maxwell
Kenny Smith
Robert Horry

Outside of Hakeem, that team is mediocre and starless. but they managed to beat the celebrated Knicks in the Finals.

Speaking of the Knicks, would Oakley make an all-star team in today's league? What role would he play? A Tristan Thompson type? Was Starks anywhere near as good as today's top guards? IMO he's a far cry from a Kyrie Irving or a Klay Thompson.

Outside of Ewing that Knicks time was wildly overrated IMO.

Who did Reggie Miller have? Rik Smits, the Davis boys and Mark Jackson? That's not a contending roster.

Jordan was the best player of this era and took advantage of some thin opposing rosters.

He never beat a team as good as the Cavs, Warriors, or probably even the current Spurs.

Re: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs
« Reply #70 on: May 08, 2017, 12:59:48 PM »

Offline Moranis

  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 34527
  • Tommy Points: 1597
I will say this: in my opinion Scottie Pippen is a better teammate than Lebron's ever had, and Pippen/Rodman trumps anything Lebron has had as well.
This is something worth digging into, for me. I've got Wade ahead of Pippen, but Pippen was a much better fit alongside Jordan than Wade was alongside Lebron. So that has to factor into this, too. Not just who had better teammates but who had the better "team". In other words whose team was better constructed to maximize its own talents and the talents of its star? I think Jordan wound up being very fortunate in that regard, especially when you take coaching into account.
Wade was definitely a better top end scorer but that is all he was better at than Pippen who was a significantly better defender and rebounder.  Wade though really only had 1 in prime season with James before the injuries started mounting up and took away much of what made Wade great.
I agree Pippen was the more versatile player but Wade was pretty versatile in his own right and I think his best was better than Pippen's best. If I'm starting a team, I'm definitely picking Wade before Pippen. On the other hand, if I already have Jordan or Lebron (or Bird or Magic) I'm picking Pippen before I pick Wade.
fair point but James didn't have prime Wade in Miami. Wade started his decline and got worse every year with James, that absolutely has to be factored in.  Especially considering all of the games Wade missed due to injury.
 Jordan played with Pippen during Pippen's entire prime (well except the year MJ took off).
I'd quibble about just when Wade started to decline (I think he was basically still in his prime those first 3 seasons, the statistical decline had to do with a role change) but I generally agree that Lebron didn't get Wade's best the whole 4 seasons.
Wade missed 17 of 66 in year 2, his mpg dropped by 4, he dropped nearly 4% from 3, took 2.5 less foul shots, rebounded less, etc.  This is from year 1 to year 2 with James so it wasn't like it was brought on by then joining up.  Year 3 wade was again injured and missed 13 games and then defensively really started his decline.

Wade wasn't a shell if himself but he wasn't peak Wade either after that first season.  His injuries really took their toll.
2023 Historical Draft - Brooklyn Nets - 9th pick

Bigs - Pau, Amar'e, Issel, McGinnis, Roundfield
Wings - Dantley, Bowen, J. Jackson
Guards - Cheeks, Petrovic, Buse, Rip

Re: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs
« Reply #71 on: May 08, 2017, 01:10:46 PM »

Offline Moranis

  • James Naismith
  • *********************************
  • Posts: 34527
  • Tommy Points: 1597
Something that has not been mentioned in this thread, it really can not be argued that the East is not incredibly flawed weak right now. Perhaps the weakest it has ever been. While I hated seeing it, it wasn't completely unjustified for people to call us the weakest number 1 seed ever. Of the top teams in the east we don't really have a superstar. Neither does Toronto. Neither does Atlanta. Perhaps Wall is the closest to a superstar in his prime in the conference on a top tier team outside of Cleveland.

Who was Lebron beating to get to the finals?

Jordan's first 3peat really had some formidable teams. One of them was, ironically, the Cavs. The Cavs had a 4 time all-star in Mark Price, Brad Daugherty a 5x all star and Larry Nance a 3x all star. What team in the east this year is closest to that?

Other notable teams in the east included the 60 win Knicks team featuring superstar and future hall of famer Ewing in his prime with both Starks and Oakley making the all star the following year.

Even at team like the Pistons had a still effective Dumars and Thomas in the all star game and Dennis Rodman pulling down an astonishing 18 rebounds a game. 

Unfortunately now when you think about the best players in the game Harden, Westbrook, Curry, Thompson, Durant, Lillard, Davis, Leonard are all in the west. How many east players even make the all-NBA teams 5 out of 15? It really is unfortunate because I would love to see the East be more competitive and the playoffs are honestly pretty boring at the moment.
The Bulls never won until the C's and Pistons declined.

Then the expansion era started, with half a dozen new teams watering down the talent pool. There were some great players in the 90's but the teams themselves had questionable depth.

The 1993 Houston Rockets won a championship with
Hakeem
Otis Thorpe
Vernon Maxwell
Kenny Smith
Robert Horry

Outside of Hakeem, that team is mediocre and starless. but they managed to beat the celebrated Knicks in the Finals.

Speaking of the Knicks, would Oakley make an all-star team in today's league? What role would he play? A Tristan Thompson type? Was Starks anywhere near as good as today's top guards? IMO he's a far cry from a Kyrie Irving or a Klay Thompson.

Outside of Ewing that Knicks time was wildly overrated IMO.

Who did Reggie Miller have? Rik Smits, the Davis boys and Mark Jackson? That's not a contending roster.

Jordan was the best player of this era and took advantage of some thin opposing rosters.

He never beat a team as good as the Cavs, Warriors, or probably even the current Spurs.
thank you. I made this point already multiple times but because I said it clay just disregards it as nonsense.  The Bulls played exactly 4 teams with multiple HOFers on the roster in their 6 title seasons and two of them were the first season Pistons and Lakers that were old, which also happens to describe the other two which were the Jazz in the last two finals.  Jordan had a very easy run during those title seasons as the both the East and West lacked any other juggernaut teams. Of the 7 teams James has played in the Finals only Dallas is comparable to those teams and the Celtics teams that Miami went through were also better teams.

You put any all time great on the Bulls with Pippen in the 90's and that team is dominating championships.  There was just a void brought on by the 80's greats falling off a cliff and all of the expansion.  The league might have looked a lot different if Bird didn't injure his back, Magic didn't get hiv, Thomas and Joe D didnt age overnight, and guys like Bias didn't kill themselves with drugs.
2023 Historical Draft - Brooklyn Nets - 9th pick

Bigs - Pau, Amar'e, Issel, McGinnis, Roundfield
Wings - Dantley, Bowen, J. Jackson
Guards - Cheeks, Petrovic, Buse, Rip

Re: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs
« Reply #72 on: May 08, 2017, 01:11:47 PM »

Offline celticsclay

  • JoJo White
  • ****************
  • Posts: 16176
  • Tommy Points: 1407
Something that has not been mentioned in this thread, it really can not be argued that the East is not incredibly flawed weak right now. Perhaps the weakest it has ever been. While I hated seeing it, it wasn't completely unjustified for people to call us the weakest number 1 seed ever. Of the top teams in the east we don't really have a superstar. Neither does Toronto. Neither does Atlanta. Perhaps Wall is the closest to a superstar in his prime in the conference on a top tier team outside of Cleveland.

Who was Lebron beating to get to the finals?

Jordan's first 3peat really had some formidable teams. One of them was, ironically, the Cavs. The Cavs had a 4 time all-star in Mark Price, Brad Daugherty a 5x all star and Larry Nance a 3x all star. What team in the east this year is closest to that?

Other notable teams in the east included the 60 win Knicks team featuring superstar and future hall of famer Ewing in his prime with both Starks and Oakley making the all star the following year.

Even at team like the Pistons had a still effective Dumars and Thomas in the all star game and Dennis Rodman pulling down an astonishing 18 rebounds a game. 

Unfortunately now when you think about the best players in the game Harden, Westbrook, Curry, Thompson, Durant, Lillard, Davis, Leonard are all in the west. How many east players even make the all-NBA teams 5 out of 15? It really is unfortunate because I would love to see the East be more competitive and the playoffs are honestly pretty boring at the moment.
The Bulls never won until the C's and Pistons declined.

Then the expansion era started, with half a dozen new teams watering down the talent pool. There were some great players in the 90's but the teams themselves had questionable depth.

The 1993 Houston Rockets won a championship with
Hakeem
Otis Thorpe
Vernon Maxwell
Kenny Smith
Robert Horry

Outside of Hakeem, that team is mediocre and starless. but they managed to beat the celebrated Knicks in the Finals.

Speaking of the Knicks, would Oakley make an all-star team in today's league? What role would he play? A Tristan Thompson type? Was Starks anywhere near as good as today's top guards? IMO he's a far cry from a Kyrie Irving or a Klay Thompson.

Outside of Ewing that Knicks time was wildly overrated IMO.

Who did Reggie Miller have? Rik Smits, the Davis boys and Mark Jackson? That's not a contending roster.

Jordan was the best player of this era and took advantage of some thin opposing rosters.

He never beat a team as good as the Cavs, Warriors, or probably even the current Spurs.

Something that has not been mentioned in this thread, it really can not be argued that the East is not incredibly flawed weak right now. Perhaps the weakest it has ever been. While I hated seeing it, it wasn't completely unjustified for people to call us the weakest number 1 seed ever. Of the top teams in the east we don't really have a superstar. Neither does Toronto. Neither does Atlanta. Perhaps Wall is the closest to a superstar in his prime in the conference on a top tier team outside of Cleveland.

Who was Lebron beating to get to the finals?

Jordan's first 3peat really had some formidable teams. One of them was, ironically, the Cavs. The Cavs had a 4 time all-star in Mark Price, Brad Daugherty a 5x all star and Larry Nance a 3x all star. What team in the east this year is closest to that?

Other notable teams in the east included the 60 win Knicks team featuring superstar and future hall of famer Ewing in his prime with both Starks and Oakley making the all star the following year.

Even at team like the Pistons had a still effective Dumars and Thomas in the all star game and Dennis Rodman pulling down an astonishing 18 rebounds a game. 

Unfortunately now when you think about the best players in the game Harden, Westbrook, Curry, Thompson, Durant, Lillard, Davis, Leonard are all in the west. How many east players even make the all-NBA teams 5 out of 15? It really is unfortunate because I would love to see the East be more competitive and the playoffs are honestly pretty boring at the moment.
The Bulls never won until the C's and Pistons declined.

Then the expansion era started, with half a dozen new teams watering down the talent pool. There were some great players in the 90's but the teams themselves had questionable depth.

The 1993 Houston Rockets won a championship with
Hakeem
Otis Thorpe
Vernon Maxwell
Kenny Smith
Robert Horry

Outside of Hakeem, that team is mediocre and starless. but they managed to beat the celebrated Knicks in the Finals.

Speaking of the Knicks, would Oakley make an all-star team in today's league? What role would he play? A Tristan Thompson type? Was Starks anywhere near as good as today's top guards? IMO he's a far cry from a Kyrie Irving or a Klay Thompson.

Outside of Ewing that Knicks time was wildly overrated IMO.

Who did Reggie Miller have? Rik Smits, the Davis boys and Mark Jackson? That's not a contending roster.

Jordan was the best player of this era and took advantage of some thin opposing rosters.

He never beat a team as good as the Cavs, Warriors, or probably even the current Spurs.

Thanks for mentioning the Pacers. That is actually a great mid level playoff team from that era. Reggie Miller is certainly a legit hall of famer, Rick Smits made an all star team, Mark Jackson is one of the NBA all-time assists leaders and the Davis Guys were a very formidable frontcourt. 

Compare that to our current Celtics team. I love IT but would be shocked if he has a hall of fame career like Miller. Horford is a nice player and a couple of times an all-star, but is also entering the back of his career. Are people going to know who Jae Crowder or Amir Johnson are 20 years from now like casual basketball fans know Jackson and Antonio Davis? Will any of our current players leaders ever be top 4 in any stat in the NBA like Jackson?

Thanks for pointing out that really solid team that Jordan also had to get through.

Re: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs
« Reply #73 on: May 08, 2017, 01:16:42 PM »

Offline celticsclay

  • JoJo White
  • ****************
  • Posts: 16176
  • Tommy Points: 1407
Something that has not been mentioned in this thread, it really can not be argued that the East is not incredibly flawed weak right now. Perhaps the weakest it has ever been. While I hated seeing it, it wasn't completely unjustified for people to call us the weakest number 1 seed ever. Of the top teams in the east we don't really have a superstar. Neither does Toronto. Neither does Atlanta. Perhaps Wall is the closest to a superstar in his prime in the conference on a top tier team outside of Cleveland.

Who was Lebron beating to get to the finals?

Jordan's first 3peat really had some formidable teams. One of them was, ironically, the Cavs. The Cavs had a 4 time all-star in Mark Price, Brad Daugherty a 5x all star and Larry Nance a 3x all star. What team in the east this year is closest to that?

Other notable teams in the east included the 60 win Knicks team featuring superstar and future hall of famer Ewing in his prime with both Starks and Oakley making the all star the following year.

Even at team like the Pistons had a still effective Dumars and Thomas in the all star game and Dennis Rodman pulling down an astonishing 18 rebounds a game. 

Unfortunately now when you think about the best players in the game Harden, Westbrook, Curry, Thompson, Durant, Lillard, Davis, Leonard are all in the west. How many east players even make the all-NBA teams 5 out of 15? It really is unfortunate because I would love to see the East be more competitive and the playoffs are honestly pretty boring at the moment.
The Bulls never won until the C's and Pistons declined.

Then the expansion era started, with half a dozen new teams watering down the talent pool. There were some great players in the 90's but the teams themselves had questionable depth.

The 1993 Houston Rockets won a championship with
Hakeem
Otis Thorpe
Vernon Maxwell
Kenny Smith
Robert Horry

Outside of Hakeem, that team is mediocre and starless. but they managed to beat the celebrated Knicks in the Finals.

Speaking of the Knicks, would Oakley make an all-star team in today's league? What role would he play? A Tristan Thompson type? Was Starks anywhere near as good as today's top guards? IMO he's a far cry from a Kyrie Irving or a Klay Thompson.

Outside of Ewing that Knicks time was wildly overrated IMO.

Who did Reggie Miller have? Rik Smits, the Davis boys and Mark Jackson? That's not a contending roster.

Jordan was the best player of this era and took advantage of some thin opposing rosters.

He never beat a team as good as the Cavs, Warriors, or probably even the current Spurs.
thank you. I made this point already multiple times but because I said it clay just disregards it as nonsense.  The Bulls played exactly 4 teams with multiple HOFers on the roster in their 6 title seasons and two of them were the first season Pistons and Lakers that were old, which also happens to describe the other two which were the Jazz in the last two finals.  Jordan had a very easy run during those title seasons as the both the East and West lacked any other juggernaut teams. Of the 7 teams James has played in the Finals only Dallas is comparable to those teams and the Celtics teams that Miami went through were also better teams.

You put any all time great on the Bulls with Pippen in the 90's and that team is dominating championships.  There was just a void brought on by the 80's greats falling off a cliff and all of the expansion.  The league might have looked a lot different if Bird didn't injure his back, Magic didn't get hiv, Thomas and Joe D didnt age overnight, and guys like Bias didn't kill themselves with drugs.

Moranis I am actually trying to address this point. One of your main points in saying Lebron is comparable to Jordan right now is the number of finals that Lebron made compared to Jordan.

I have been pointing out that the teams that Jordan had to get past every year in the east through the late 80 and the early 90's had multiple in their prime all stars. Compared to this, Lebron has had an extremely easy path getting to the finals the last 2 seasons and this season.
You have teams like the Wizards, Celtics, Raptors that have either 1 or at most 2 all stars. Of this group I think only Wall would be considered an in his prime all star. Can you really refute that and say these other teams in the top 4 are comparable to a Cavs team that had 3 multiple time all stars that Jordan beat every year? To me it isn't close.

I also think if you are consistent with yourself you agree the east has been pathetic the last couple of seasons cause I know you don't think the Celtics are a great team, yet were able to win the most games in it this year.

Also to be clear, I do give Lebron credit where it is due. Beating the warriors last year was very impressive, injuries and suspensions and all, that was a really good team that he beat once he got there and I give him credit for that. If he is able to win again this year and beat that team he will get even more credit and it becomes a lot closer.

However, he does not get credit for making the east finals when there are no legitimate contenders in it. If he is a superstar playing alongside two legit all stars and an embarrassment of riches as role players he NEEDs to do that and it gets him no closer to Jordan. It should also be pointed out that part of the reason the east became so bad during the start of his finals run is because in the process of forming the big 3 in Miami he gutted two promising potential contenders in the process. If Bosh stays in Toronto and grows with Derozen and they add a few more pieces, how good does that team become? Maybe they still get Lowry because they got him for cheap. Isn't that a very impressive team for Lebron to have to go through each year?

« Last Edit: May 08, 2017, 01:24:03 PM by celticsclay »

Re: LeBron will likely pass Jordan this playoffs
« Reply #74 on: May 08, 2017, 01:25:47 PM »

Offline Big333223

  • NCE
  • Tiny Archibald
  • *******
  • Posts: 7833
  • Tommy Points: 770
I will say this: in my opinion Scottie Pippen is a better teammate than Lebron's ever had, and Pippen/Rodman trumps anything Lebron has had as well.
This is something worth digging into, for me. I've got Wade ahead of Pippen, but Pippen was a much better fit alongside Jordan than Wade was alongside Lebron. So that has to factor into this, too. Not just who had better teammates but who had the better "team". In other words whose team was better constructed to maximize its own talents and the talents of its star? I think Jordan wound up being very fortunate in that regard, especially when you take coaching into account.
Wade was definitely a better top end scorer but that is all he was better at than Pippen who was a significantly better defender and rebounder.  Wade though really only had 1 in prime season with James before the injuries started mounting up and took away much of what made Wade great.
I agree Pippen was the more versatile player but Wade was pretty versatile in his own right and I think his best was better than Pippen's best. If I'm starting a team, I'm definitely picking Wade before Pippen. On the other hand, if I already have Jordan or Lebron (or Bird or Magic) I'm picking Pippen before I pick Wade.
fair point but James didn't have prime Wade in Miami. Wade started his decline and got worse every year with James, that absolutely has to be factored in.  Especially considering all of the games Wade missed due to injury.
 Jordan played with Pippen during Pippen's entire prime (well except the year MJ took off).
I'd quibble about just when Wade started to decline (I think he was basically still in his prime those first 3 seasons, the statistical decline had to do with a role change) but I generally agree that Lebron didn't get Wade's best the whole 4 seasons.
Wade missed 17 of 66 in year 2, his mpg dropped by 4, he dropped nearly 4% from 3, took 2.5 less foul shots, rebounded less, etc. This is from year 1 to year 2 with James so it wasn't like it was brought on by then joining up.  Year 3 wade was again injured and missed 13 games and then defensively really started his decline.

Wade wasn't a shell if himself but he wasn't peak Wade either after that first season.  His injuries really took their toll.
My memory is that that first year Lebron was in Miami, Lebron was trying to let it be Wade's team and they tried to share the ball but after the loss in the Finals, Wade played a lot more off ball. That's what I'm talking about when I say I attribute Wade's stat dip those next 2 seasons was due (mostly) to role change.
1957, 1959, 1960, 1961, 1962, 1963, 1964, 1965, 1966, 1968, 1969, 1974, 1976, 1981, 1984, 1986, 2008, 2024