Not one of these points you raise address the fact that he is a 24 year-old big who started for a 48 win team and put up 10 and 8 per game, while being 15th in the NBA in total rebound % and 10th in the NBA in defensive rating.
If his offer sheet is $9M or less, we should match it.
On 44% shooting. That is a pretty inefficient 10 PPG. He is also ranked, 15th in scoring, 20th in FG%, 16th in RPG. 38th in BPG, 8th in APG. Which pretty much backs up what we said, he can pass, can rebound though not at the elite level everyone states but still good at it, and he can't shoot. Consider that defensive rating required us to go sign Amir. But he is a middle of the road in most stats. His natural position would be PF but he is too slow to cover them so that is not an option. He also can't stay at a decent playing weight, has conditioning issues. Who gains weight during the season? He will always be a guy who requires certain players around him to compensate for his weaknesses.
If he is as good as you say, then why haven't other teams signed him right away? A bunch of teams passed him up on draft night, they did their homework. So far, free agency, has not went the way he hoped. There is a reason for this and the reason is he has baggage. I like our energy level more without him. We were also more fun to watch and had a nice run without him the year before last year when he ate himself to a foot injury.
If no offers more than the QO then it would be foolish to offer more. His playoffs this year was horrific. This GUY IS HIS OWN WORST ENEMY sadly. He doesn't take personal responsibility for his condition and blames it on his metabolism which is not shoving food in his mouth. It may contribute to his malady but he still has a great deal of control of this situation which he hides behind his metabolism excuse. If a team offers 8-9 million, I would only match or exceed if it was a one year contract. From now, on if he stays here, he should be facing one year contracts with weight clauses. His health or back could take a turn for the worst with all the weight on it. I do not wish him hurt but this is reality. Excess weight is hard on anyone.
I think after reading Bulpett's comments and the tweet, we may be hearing a renounce of his rights. Ainge has finally had enough of his antics. Maybe he is working out a sign and trade so he can get something out of it for him.
Should be interesting to find out more. Wonder if he did this just to remind GMs he is out there, sort of a PR stunt.