I'm not sure we have the roster space for him. Especially if you figure we add at least two players in the draft plus other free agents we could use more than him. I just don't see where he warrants a spot.
That's a good point but consider that ET and Sully might leave the team. Maybe Zeller and Amir too depending on what happens the next few months. And I would not see James Young as a lock either, esp. if we sign a big in the FA. Add to this that we already have an empty roster post and this adds up to 6
potentially free roster posts.
Of the people drafted I expect that only 3-4 or four will sign to play with the team this year. We will either trade several picks for another team's one pick or stash the second rounders abroad.
So, if necessary we can add Dudley, add 3 rookies, and still have two spots available for FAs. This scenario is obviously a stretch, but if we see it as a improving our position we might as well do something similar.