The "true fan" stuff is specifically against our rules, it's one of Jeff Clark's pet peeves, and it is the height of arrogance. Who here has the monopoly on defining how fans must act?
Show a little humility, and follow our rules.
The rules don't say you can't discuss what it means to be a fan. The rules do say you can't label people, and I wasn't trying to do that. I'm not saying I'm a great fan and so-and-so isn't. I was just asking why if you hate the playoffs so much you bother to be a fan, because to me this is the most enjoyable part. Even if you lose, you always have some shot to win until it's all over.
I wasn't trying to bait anyone into an argument. I see the thread for what it is, frustration from getting spanked in game 2. I get that, I was just trying t put it in perspective. Make people think a bit. I don't think that people posting that they wish it was all over, really mean that and that was what I was trying to get at. I guess I could have been more tactful.
Rule number 4 on the rule page is "Have fun!" If any rule breaking should be looked into it is this one.
You could have followed the rules. All of the following violate our rules:
How do some of you here get off calling yourselves Celtics fans?
Being a true fan is enjoying that.
you have a lot to learn about being a fan.
You're not the arbiter of who is or isn't a "true fan", and condescendingly asking others how they can justify calling themselves a fan is beyond acceptable. It's judgmental, it's arrogant, and it's against our rules. If you want to suggest different rules, do it in the Comments and Remarks thread, but this one isn't going to change.
I guess you got me on the 1st and 3rd quote. But the 2nd one? Where in the rules does it say you can't share your opinion of what being a a fan is?
My mistake on the other ones was really using the word "you" or "some of you." I should have disagreed with the the comment not the poster. Like you have done Roy. You didn't call me arrogant and judgmental. You used the term "it" instead of "you." I mean the result is the same. I can tell what you think of me, but you did it within the rules.
The thing is though, that the rule says:
Do not label or challenge fellow posters -- either individually or collectively -- in a way that is likely to provoke a negative response.
I didn't get any negative response (except for you telling me I broke the rules.) No one bothered to reply saying anything negative except you.
Hemingway these ops are fair guys. I know you want to argue your side , but trust me this time you won't get far and will actually win by saying these two words I say to my wife when I'm in the rabbbit hole. "yes dear"
Anyways going back to the main topic. Off season couldn't come soon enough, let's tank, let's lose on purpose, let's be like the hawks/heat and manipulate placement in standings
It's all bad things to do. The baskteball gods will eventually make you pay a price
We win tonight and I want to win game 4. And beat the Cavs even though the odds are heavily against us. Then who knows
This is a wonderful unit. Hard to dislike. Reminds me of that pistons team with Prince, Hamilton etc. Hardworking , team 1st mentality group of guys