Simmons will go 1st. But I think many agree Ingram would be a better fit for our team.
Ingram fits better for the Celts. Simmons has a higher ceiling if he can ever learn to consistently shoot the 3. He just has to make the open ones
How good of a fit is Evan Turner right now? Evan Turner at his best is basically giving us a preview of how well Simmons would fit his first couple of years, except at PF not SF probably, which might even make a young Simmons fit even better, because he could start next to Crowder, whereas Ingram would have to sub in for or supplant Crowder or push Crowder to PF. I get that we need more scoring, and that Ingram looks like he'll become a really good scorer, but he won't be a really good scorer right off the bat. By the time he is, every other position on the team would be open again as a spot to plug in a really good scorer, and there'd be way more options on the trade and free agent market to get one. Simmons will be a really good rebounder, facilitator, and finisher right away. I think Simmons is the better fit for 2017 & 2018, and the obvious #1 pick.