Isn't it crazy that a year ago it'd be ridiculous to think that Crowder would net Love in a trade. Now I'm almost not sure I'd want to give Crowder up for him... Crowder is tough and he's a winner, Love isn't. Crowder has become the backbone of this team
It's truly nuts. Crowder was almost a non-entity, decent filler, an afterthought in a generally disappointing Rondo trade. Love was worth the #1 overall pick. How the lowly have risen, how the mighty have stumbled down.
Crowder really is the backbone now. Barring the acquisition of a first-tier go-to superstar, the way these Celtics are going to become a contender is through a defensive identity that unexpectedly disrupts the offensive identity of the Warriors, Spurs, and/or Cavs. Defense equalizes. It's futile to try to out-offense that kind of offensive firepower.
The Celtics have a team defense that's nearly good enough on its own already to stay in games with the league's elite. Any move where defense is sacrificed for offense is going to be lateral, no matter how good the offense.
Love as an overall asset is worth more than Crowder in a vacuum, yes. But sacrificing Crowder's defense to get Love would, for this particular team, be taking one step forward and one step back. If there weren't a surplus of picks then it might be different, C's might be forced to give up a core player to gamble on getting extra production. But the picks let Ainge wait for the ideal opportunity of using just picks + filler inserting a star into a fully-formed supporting cast, preferably a defensive star, which Love is not. Love would obviously help turn the C's from bad to good on the glass. But the other team has to miss the shots first. Love is a negative there, he needs a player like Crowder next to him, plus a center to protect the rim. Crowder for Love, one year later, is not worth it, will backfire.
If the Cavs would take Sullinger, plus the best non-Brooklyn picks, plus filler, then great. But they won't. If Ainge can find a three-team situation, great. Otherwise just wait to cash in a combination of lower-impact assets and non-core players to get a defense-minded big who can rebound about as well as Love. A rental of Whiteside for relative scraps, a better package of assets for a long-term answer with upside like Noel, something like that. Or cash in the very best assets for a legit superstar-caliber two-way player like Cousins. Love just isn't good enough now to give up that kind of max trade offer, not good enough overall. C's just can't afford to be any kind of team that doesn't compete to be the best in the league on defense. Crowder for Love, let alone adding picks, Bradley, etc. would a case of winner's curse we'd regret for years.