I think if you are the Celtics, and you have an opportunity to trade for someone like Kevin Love, you simply have to try to do it. That doesn't mean you make a bad trade, or overpay. If the price is right though, you try to make a deal happen. The Celtics have a lot of good complimentary, and good role players. They have no real stars. I like some of the players a lot, but you aren't going very far when Crowder, Bradley, Sully, etc. make up the top echelon on your roster. In the NBA you need allstars at the top. While Love's star has certainly fallen, and his level of eliteness is certainly in question, he's still better than anything the Celtics have in the front court. In the NBA you trade quarters for a 50 cent piece all day long. Quarters you can find. Allstar players are a different story. I'd try hard to avoid moving Crowder, cuz I love what he brings, and his contract is proving to be pretty reasonable moving forward.
My take on a Love deal is this:
Olynyk + Bradley + Lee + Turner
for
Love + Kaun
I believe Cleveland would have to use some of its trade exception money to make this work. I think this is doable for Cleveland. Bradley gives them a solid back court option on both ends of the floor, at reasonable dollars. Olynyk gives them similar attributes that Love gives (stretch 4) on rookie money, while Lee and Turner provide veteran minutes on expiring deals. I think each player would strengthen the Cavs second unit, which come playoff time is critical for a contender if they want to win a title.
The Celtics have to get rid of some bodies. They have to cull the herd if you will. They have something like a dozen top 35 or so picks in the next few years, as well as a roster full of young players with talent, who need minutes to develop. It might stink to give up some young guys we like, but that's what you have to do in the NBA in order to acquire an allstar. None of the players in this proposal will ever be better than Kevin Love, and that's the key thing to consider.
One of the problems with a proposal like this is what it means for Cleveland this year, in terms of the luxury tax. It adds money to them this year, but it saves money for them moving forward. Is that something they would consider? If not, then the teams would have to figure out a way to lessen this years tax blow. Maybe offer up a draft pick(s) for anyone willing to take on Varajeo's deal.